Heck yeah. Why draft the next Tippa when you can keep the next Tyson Slattery on the list for another year.
As others are saying, having rookies be allowed to play at any time is a new twist. My guess is it will make the re-rookie even more common among the teams that love it so much. Get the national draft pick instead of rookie draft pick, still get to play them whenever your preferred option is the 40th best player on your list.
Thereās not a great deal of difference wit hthe rookie list anymore - Primary A rookie listed players can all play from round 1 - correct me if iām wrong?
I think it depends on how you define it as working
If itās a list spot viewed in isolation, vs proportion of successes overal then sure, in the majority it hasnāt worked
If itās compared to the success or otherwise of comparable picks, I think itās probably much of a muchness
But in reality, half of those guys were halfway through a contract, and were going to be around anyway in some way, shape or form. The only actual decision was leave them on the main list and take a 3rd (or 4th or 5th) rookie pick; or demote them to rookies and take a 4th (or 5th or 6th) national draft pick or FA or cheap trade.
You can attract players to your main list, but nobodyās coming here to be a rookie.
Ie Eades as rookie + Stewart
vs Eades still on main list + best of whoever was left in the 3rd round of the rookie draft [ironically probably some other clubās retread like Joel Patfull or Fraser Mcinnes]
On balance Iād give a 1 year extension to Morga now and work out whether he sits on the main or rookie list once we know whatās happenijg with the older guys. Quite likely weāre doing 6-8 main list changes anyway.
I found this one particularly strange. Like Redman stood out over all other draftees and needed to be guaranteed 4 years straight away like other clubs were scrambling for his signature. I get that he is a light body and might need more time but just thought at the time he hadn;t really shown anything yet anyway.
Also i liked the comments elsewhere of Morgan being given a try right in the middle, he is actually a big body for his age, quick and seems ordinary in defence.
Interested to see Ridley this weekend too.
When it becomes apparent that a player doesnāt have the intensity or appetite for the contest required of AFL, you cut your loses. Morgan is that player in my opinion.