And as long as there are so many grey areas, umpires, who are just flawed humans like us all, will continue to overly influence a game with their ‘interpretations’.
If I was offered a week off for hitting someone in the guts at work, I reckon I’d be tempted to do it once a month. If someone said I’d have to cough up $1500 instead, I’d be far less keen.
Most players are on a contract where they get paid for each game played. Depending on who they are that could be $4000 - $5000 a game.
Also player’s bonuses (and sometimes contract extensions) may be tied to how many games they play or where they finish in the B&F etc. So players don’t like missing games.
Honestly KM, I think you need to watch that again. It was a contested ball and Cotchin went at it hard. It’s that type of attack at the ball that elevated him to the next level imo.
But you’re right saying if it was ZM then he’d get rubbed out.
Good idea in theory but if the umpires get it wrong it would be too costly. Currently, if they report you and are wrong you play out the game and work it out at the tribunal. If they had the sin bin rule you could lose your best player for the last 5 minutes of a grand final only to have it overturned after the game because the umpire made a mistake.
Disagree. There is nothing in our game that prevents a player from intentionally taking out an opposition star in a GF, and then accepting the 6-8 week penalty. They’d even be considered a ‘hero’ by the team supporters. I’d happily have a sin-bin for intentional stuff, followed by additional tribunal post-match if required.
Yeah but we’re talking gut punches here. For the Gaff type stuff i wouldn’t hate the idea assuming they can get it right. And when was the last time a player deliberately took out a star from another team in a GF? It’s not the 80s any more.