#2 Big Sammy Draper (from May 2024)

Who do people think draper is currently a better overall ruckman than in the comp?

Adelaide - Reilly O’Brien
Briabane - Oscar mcinernerny
Carlton - TDK
Collingwood - Darcy Cameron
Freo - Sean Darcy
Geelong - Mark Blicavs
Gold Coast - Jarrod witts
GWS - Kieran Briggs
Hawthorn - Lloyd Meek
Melbourne - Max Gawn
North Tristan Xerri
Port - Jordon Sweet
Richmond - Toby Nankervis
St Kilda - Rohan Marshall
Sydney - Brodie Grundy
West Coast - Bailey Williams
Western bulldogs - Tim English

1 Like

nobody!

2 Likes

Probably Bailey Williams and that’s about it but Williams can kick and beats him on pressure acts so maybe it’s a toss of the coin

1 Like

He’d be lucky to be in the top 10 among that list

1 Like

I reckon its pretty obvious he isnt…

6 Likes

Haha…I also did this exercise off the top of my head this without looking at club lists and came up with about 21 ruckman before you’d even think about Draper.

2 Likes

Wimm right now…

3 Likes

There’s second in line ruckman like Jackson, Cox, Sweet and the young GCS ruckman who offer more.

He’d be lucky to be the 25th best ruckman in the league

2 Likes

Add Moyle and pittonet to that list he barley scraps into the top 30

Draper has a long way to go. But if there’s one area in footy stats that do lie, it’s comparing ruckmen’s stats. Draper has done a lot of sharing of ruck duties, with both Phillips and Goldy, since Scott took over. So you wouldn’t expect him to be in the leading categories.

fair effort to not get a ban after todays tanty

Average and fast becoming one of the most hated players in the comp if the socials are anything to go by. I think half of them are Essendon supporters.

You may have missed the eyes lowered 30 metre bullet to Langford last week second quarter.
His kicking has reached the point where he’s getting plenty of distance, and is more reliable to boot.
The handballs to someone running past are getting predictable to other teams so would like to see him take advantage of the space in front of him, take a gallop and kick it to the goal square.

2 Likes

He literally does that every time (gallop and go
long)

Mind boggling that we went tall against Geelong and Melbourne in wet weather, when we had 2 or 3 in and under contested players playing VFL.

2 Likes

Agreed - and it is another pointer to a lack of selection integrity and flexibility. Scott would rather jam his very fixed idea of his best 23 into a line up even where it results in the team being unbalanced and even in the face of conditions demanding something different.

He just doesn’t seem to have any footy smarts

His tap work varies between sublime and trash

1 Like

Sublime? Stretch to call anything Draper does as sublime.

1 Like

sublime vibes

2 Likes

I’m not a massive Draper fan but those hit out stats don’t really mean a lot when it doesn’t factor in time in ruck. It would be weighted towards teams who predominantly only use one ruckman like Melbourne, Bulldogs, StKilda, etc. if we played only Draper in the ruck his rating would improve.