2018 Pre Season Discussion

I didn’t mind Woosha mentioning adapting to the new game plan as one possible factor contributing to the WangSlaughter; but I’ve heard the confusion line trotted out too many times in the media and by our players. The idea we got belted because we were confused between required defensive structures and playing on instinct seems unprofessional. Being so under-prepared would be ok for a bottom 4 rebuild team full of draft picks but we have higher aspirations so we better start thinking and talking like a top 4 team.

We need to kill off that excuse or at least shelve it never to be mentioned in public again.

1 Like

On the contrary, I think it is an extremely natural and likely scenario. Learning a tweaked game plan, trying to embed and instill it, getting players during pre-season to adopt it naturally - then the first outing, being stiff and swinging between the newly trained stuff, the older structures, and natural flair. I don’t think it unprofessional in the slightest. It is the most natural and obvious result.

2 Likes

Having so many first team omissions and players under illness clouds doesn’t help.

I’d be circumspect about how much stock you put in relayed ‘insider information’.

Every club will have a new game plan or significant changes to the old one. Of course they will get better at it during the season but it doesn’t at all explain being completely noncompetitive.

I understand how it could, given a whole list of circumstances that have been outlined in this thread a few times.

Another year, another excuse ? Last year it was the team needed to “gel”. Again.

In effect, McGrath, Jobe, Hurls, Hooker and TBell together with year on year improvement of the 2016 players took us from last to 7th. ( with a bit of help from a couple of others)
This year we are adding just 3 new best 22 players, so the need to gel and scope for confusion should be a bit less. We already saw how Smith fitted seamlessly into the team in JLT1.

2 Likes

There’s a big difference between getting possessions and fitting seamlessly into the team.
( hi figjam Buckley)
Confusion was clearly there among the mids and moving the ball into the forward line effectively.
Smith got stats but was no means blameless in both these areas.- it will get better.

I would see a bigger problem if they refused to admit that it was a problem.

2 Likes

Perhaps the players are lid on?

I think the aim was to reset it as that nil all draw, 50-60 out.

FYI (from looking at the numbers) it seems like we had fewer boundary throwins than any other club last year. Obviously part of the plan, somehow.

What I remember the most about the 2000 and 93 and 85 and 84 teams is how they talked.

2 Likes

I’m just glad we don’t have to play the Tigers till round 11 hopefuly by then we have a couple of wins notched up.

2 wins by round 11?

Who would we take as #1 draft pick?

2 Likes

Obviously we go the best half back available…

7 Likes

And we did indeed find out. Reckon your source was right that something was amiss with Orazio.

You have a good connection, nickers.

1 Like

One of those things that I was hoping to be wrong about. Different injury but not great news regardless. :slightly_frowning_face:

Mclugage for mine. Just gets the ball all the time and knows how tokicks goals.

Mids can aim high, Kelly
Callum Twomey, AFL Media March 9, 2018 11:45 AM

Performance coach James Kelly says Essendon’s midfield can match it with the league’s best.

Essendon’s new-look midfield has what it takes to compete with the best engine rooms around the competition this season, according to assistant coach and retired Bomber James Kelly.

The club’s midfield group will be centred around some different faces this season, with Jobe Watson retiring at the end of 2017, and veteran Brendon Goddard set for more time across half-back.

The Bombers added Devon Smith and Jake Stringer during the trade period and both are expected to feature prominently in the midfield, which will be vital for Essendon’s hopes after they were bullied by a strong Sydney onball unit in last year’s elimination final.

In their first JLT Community Series clash with Richmond, the Bombers again struggled to match the bigger bodies of the Tigers around the ball, losing the clearance count 34-26. But Kelly is confident the club has enough depth to challenge the top sides.

“We’ll get a bit more footy from David Myers [as an] inside [midfielder], Dyson Heppell plays inside and Jake Stringer comes in there. Darcy Parish is only getting bigger and stronger every year as well,” Kelly told AFL.com.au.

"We might not have a Josh Kennedy (from Sydney) in our side, but we have a lot of players who can share the load, and that’s always the philosophy that we have. We’re not looking for one person to go and get us 15 clearances a game, but for everyone to play their role and do their bit, and we spread the load.

“A lot of teams that I’ve seen with a good even spread, if one goes down someone else will bob up. That’s something we’ve been working on.”

Essendon will face a good test in its second and final pre-season hit-out when it comes up against Geelong in Colac on Sunday. The Cats have named midfield guns Patrick Dangerfield and Joel Selwood, but Gary Ablett will not play after a niggling hamstring injury surfaced late last month.

With All Australian pair Michael Hurley and Cale Hooker among the key inclusions, a better performance will be expected from the Bombers after their 87-point loss to the Tigers.

Kelly, who retired last season after two seasons with the Bombers having come out of retirement after a stellar career at Geelong, described the game as the Bombers’ main “dress rehearsal” ahead of their round one clash with Grand Finalists Adelaide.

The development coach added there wouldn’t be as much experimentation this week compared to their first outing.

“This time of the year you’re always tinkering with little things and seeing what’s going to work, and ideas you have you might implement them for a quarter and not the next quarter. It is a little bit unsettling for the players,” he said.

"I’ve been in that position, so I understand that sometimes you just want a full run at it and you don’t want coaches messing with things. Being on the other side of that now, we want to have a look at certain players in certain spots and what things look like in preparation for the year.

“There’ll be less of that this week and more trying to get that chemistry going and trying to look forward to round one.”

The Bombers won’t be quite at full-strength, however, after livewire forward Orazio Fantasia underwent knee surgery on Thursday. He will miss at least round one as he recovers.

“He’s frustrated by it, as everyone else is, but that’s footy,” Kelly said.

“These things sometimes you can manage players through them and they get better and sometimes you can’t. This is unfortunately for ‘Raz’ once of those times we couldn’t manage him through it, so it was time to make a decision.”

3 Likes

Lost the clearance count by 8

Thought it would be worse than that against the regining premeirs adding Myers and Bellchambers will help