#22 - Jake Carlisle: Gone

Riolio · November 4, 2015, 2:00am

While true he was a talented player, this whole saga makes him seem like quite the tool.

chris_64 · November 4, 2015, 2:01am

I bow to those with detailed memories of each game . My comments were an overall impression. As for being the general and organising the defence, I had the distinct impression that Fletch was that until 2014. Maybe I am wrong again. Anyone ?

wimmera1 · November 4, 2015, 2:01am

While true he was a talented player, this whole saga makes him seem like quite the tool.

Literal lol.
This whole saga?

Westing_Wuckman · November 4, 2015, 2:09am

While true he was a talented player, this whole saga makes him seem like quite the tool.

Literal lol.
This whole saga?

Yes thissh whole thorry thorry tharga.

sorry, couldn’t help myself.

Westing_Wuckman · November 4, 2015, 2:10am

Why is Jake’s dad out playing golf instead of being a good parent? Family Governance.

wimmera1 · November 4, 2015, 2:12am

While true he was a talented player, this whole saga makes him seem like quite the tool.

Literal lol.
This whole saga?

Yes thissh whole thorry thorry tharga.

sorry, couldn’t help myself.

Theriothly, if this was a saga Carisle’s name wouldn’t fit on the spine.
And how does it end? Oh, Essendon got what they wanted, just like all the other sagas…

Riolio · November 4, 2015, 2:22am

While true he was a talented player, this whole saga makes him seem like quite the tool.

Literal lol.
This whole saga?

The one he brought on himself? Yeah.

Westing_Wuckman · November 4, 2015, 2:23am

This should be an axis of rotational symmetry question (pole): Where does Carlisle rank in the measure of tooliness?

James Hird
Cale Hooker
A quality person who has made a few minor mistakes and has already been punished far in excess of what is reasonable. By and large did the right thing by his club on the way out.
This whole saga makes him seem quite the tool
Westing Wuckman
Chris Judd
Patrick Ryder
Joseph Stalin

wimmera1 · November 4, 2015, 2:28am

While true he was a talented player, this whole saga makes him seem like quite the tool.

Literal lol.
This whole saga?

The one he brought on himself? Yeah.

You’re killing me.
Yeah, he should totally have stopped Dank from coming.

wimmera1 · November 4, 2015, 2:31am

This should be an axis of rotational symmetry question (pole): Where does Carlisle rank in the measure of tooliness?

James Hird

Cale Hooker

A quality person who has made a few minor mistakes and has already been punished far in excess of what is reasonable. By and large did the right thing by his club on the way out.

Westing Wuckman

David Evans

Chris Judd

McFarkstick

wimmera1

This whole saga makes him seem quite the tool

Patrick Ryder

Joseph Stalin

Fixed.

Riolio · November 4, 2015, 2:32am

While true he was a talented player, this whole saga makes him seem like quite the tool.

Literal lol.
This whole saga?

The one he brought on himself? Yeah.

You’re killing me.
Yeah, he should totally have stopped Dank from coming.

Continue to misunderstand me at your leisure. I’m done.

DonsForEver · November 4, 2015, 2:35am

Not sure Ryder comes in before Stalin, personally.

wimmera1 · November 4, 2015, 2:36am

While true he was a talented player, this whole saga makes him seem like quite the tool.

Literal lol.
This whole saga?

The one he brought on himself? Yeah.

You’re killing me.
Yeah, he should totally have stopped Dank from coming.

Continue to misunderstand me at your leisure. I’m done.

I don’t think I misunderstand you, I just think you’re deliberately ignoring 95% of the situation.

BLOODSTAINED_DEVILS · November 4, 2015, 2:45am

If, as I believe/d, you were saying we should lay off jake because he did the right thing when he left Wim, I’m with you.

If otoh you are saying Dank & the EFC saga is in someway responsible for his current predicament he’s got himself into, & that if not for that, he wouldn’t have used a recreational drug off season & then been so dumb as to post it on the web in any way, … I reckon you’re on your Pat Malone there.

Edit: Maybe you were both just being deliberately obtuse …

IceTemple · November 4, 2015, 2:54am

While true he was a talented player, this whole saga makes him seem like quite the tool.

Literal lol.
This whole saga?

The one he brought on himself? Yeah.

You’re killing me.
Yeah, he should totally have stopped Dank from coming.

Continue to misunderstand me at your leisure. I’m done.

I don’t think I misunderstand you, I just think you’re deliberately ignoring 95% of the situation.

TBH you appear to be looking like a tool in this saga

wimmera1 · November 4, 2015, 3:03am

While true he was a talented player, this whole saga makes him seem like quite the tool.

Literal lol.
This whole saga?

The one he brought on himself? Yeah.

You’re killing me.
Yeah, he should totally have stopped Dank from coming.

Continue to misunderstand me at your leisure. I’m done.

I don’t think I misunderstand you, I just think you’re deliberately ignoring 95% of the situation.

TBH you appear to be looking like a tool in this saga

I’m a tool in all the sagas.
Popularity is no measure of accuracy.

Reboot · November 4, 2015, 3:04am

Jake is 24 years old … he ■■■■■■ up … it happens … won’t hang him for that.
He did the right thing by us on the way out … for me that counts.
He played some mighty good footy for us … for me that counts too.
Even with the ■■■■ ups I wish he still played for us … for me that counts too.

AT77 · November 4, 2015, 3:05am

I seriously don't get the hate/mental ■■■■■■■ at his expense. This is a guy who could have easily chosen Carlton. Easily.
I hope he tears it up next season.
I hope one of the biggest discussions at the end of 2016 is how you fit Hurley, Hooker and Carlisle into the AA team.

You forgot the greatest defender in the history of the game Alex Raaaaaance, he will make it even if he plays no more than 5 games

wimmera1 · November 4, 2015, 3:06am

If, as I believe/d, you were saying we should lay off jake because he did the right thing when he left Wim, I'm with you.
If otoh you are saying Dank & the EFC saga is in someway responsible for his current predicament he’s got himself into, & that if not for that, he wouldn’t have used a recreational drug off season & then been so dumb as to post it on the web in any way, … I reckon you’re on your Pat Malone there.

Edit: Maybe you were both just being deliberately obtuse …

I’m saying THE saga is responsible for All Of The Predicaments.
I’m saying if you think Carlisle is the only Essendon player to snort Charlie then I have a bridge to sell you.

He didn’t post it on the web, his mate sold it to the papes.
Whatever, do you want me to hate him for being dumb?
How dumb were you in your early twenties?

Davo · November 4, 2015, 3:06am

While true he was a talented player, this whole saga makes him seem like quite the tool.

Literal lol.
This whole saga?

The one he brought on himself? Yeah.

You’re killing me.
Yeah, he should totally have stopped Dank from coming.

Continue to misunderstand me at your leisure. I’m done.

I don’t think I misunderstand you, I just think you’re deliberately ignoring 95% of the situation.

You’re misunderstanding what Rolo was saying. You actually are.