I don’t reckon the other reasons would have mattered as much, if he was still in AA form.
any bloke that can kick more than 2 goals a game in this team this season is a friggin godsend
he must be thinking he’ll have to take on a mentoring role, being the lesser headcase in the situation he has found himself in
bold strategy cotton, lets hope it pays off
Hell kick 5 this week!
In the VFL
Adding him to our list was the right thing to do.
Giving him limited but increasing minutes in the midfield is the right thing to do.
It’s one of the few things we’ve got right.
Actually think he won’t play this week.
Woosha said he would “possibly” play and he’s “in line for selection”
One was extremely fit and could run all day. The other isn’t.
He’s a downhill skier of the highest order
He’ll be a very good player if the team ever gets up and going. That’s how he is
He’s getting criticised because his body language is appalling. Also has a knack of getting to positions around stoppages where the is zero chance of the ball getting too. That is a skill in itself. Called self preservation.
Looks like he couldn’t give a toss. Maybe he does. Deserves all the criticism he gets
Anyone who is surprised by Stringer’s up and down performances paid zero attention to his thread when the trade was being made. There were ample warnings to expect inconsistency in his games. He will come good, he was never going to come in and be a quick fix, match winner, straight out of the box.
Not ready to throw in the towel he’ll come good I doubt we could have got anyone better in the draft with two 2nd rd picks.
Very generous of you not being ready to throw in the towel after less than half a season. Very generous.
Not Juddy’s biggest fan but this is a good article.
Stringer theory: He needs to grow up
There is barely anything in the world more selfish than a newborn baby. Granted, they are not without their tricks: so cute and cuddly, with a smell on the top of their head that is hard not to kiss.
But, understandably, they have no ability yet to care for or even comprehend the needs of others, they’re often and justifiably terrified, and they are completely dependent on the goodwill of others to survive.
A common thread among religions is the journey from the selfishness of a newborn to selflessness. Since football is a microcosm of life, fans can see this journey from selfishness to selflessness play out as players mature and grow throughout their careers.
An 18-year-old draftee has the same sort of understandable selfishness as a newborn. His initial desire is more about getting a first game rather than the premiership; that craving will come later. He’s often scared and needs the physical protection of others. The breadth of view necessary to understand the needs and importance of all the different club stakeholders does not yet exist.
After a year or two, he grows into football’s version of the cocky adolescent. He’s unpredictable. He’s capable of brilliance, but also of selfish mistakes, while often surprising even himself with his new-found strength.
Next comes football’s version of adulthood, where he’s able to drive others, sacrifice the moment for the future, and understand that the club is bigger than merely the players and the coaches. If he is of outstanding character, gifted with huge ability, plays long enough and is in a good enough system, he might even find football’s version of enlightenment (I’m looking at you, Shaun Burgoyne).
Unfortunately for Essendon, Jake Stringer looks like he’s stuck in the adolescent phase. I try to avoid the “pile on” dynamic of AFL media towards any story that fits the “if it bleeds it leads” category. But Essendon and Stringer will be the story this week, and Jake should expect that after laying only four tackles in his past three games, and generally quiet performances, it will be his turn to take some heat.
I’m thinking not just about his refusal to make sacrificial leads, creating space for others, and his unwillingness to pressure the opposition, but specifically about two acts late in the game.
The first happened with 6:12 left on the clock in the last quarter when Mark Baguley courageously marked a high ball about 55 metres out from Essendon’s goal. He went back, looking for an option, only for Stringer to sprint away from Essendon’s goal and call for a handball while going to his left foot surrounded by many Carlton players who could apply pressure on him.
When he didn’t receive the handball, Stringer’s immediate opponent rightly sagged off him, creating an extra spare in Essendon’s forward 50, making it even harder for Baguley to hit a target.
Only a few minutes later, Darcy Parish marked within what looked to be kicking range, only to have Stringer run past for a handball, which he received before putting the ball out on the full.
Couple the way he is playing with the pre-season peroxided blond haircut, the fact that he forgot his match-day pass in round one and felt the need share the experience on social media pre-game. Consider the difference between what he says about wanting to spend more time in the midfield and the lack of transformation in his body shape to allowing that.
It all speaks of a player who is desperate for attention (as teenagers often are), but is currently unwilling to put in the work, and sacrifice enough of the “present” to earn positive attention from productive on-field actions.
I suspect Stringer will be dropped this week. As Essendon are no longer in finals contention, it becomes a reasonably simple time to focus on decisions around principle as opposed to the shorter-term needs of winning a match.
Some will say that Stringer is lucky because he was born with natural athletic ability. I’d say he’s unlucky, because he’s going to have to earn his maturity instead of it evolving naturally like it does for most.
If he can avoid being defensive about feedback, start to cultivate genuine care for the needs of others and his club, and look to players close by like Devon Smith, who is firmly entrenched as the type of footballing “adult” you need to become to achieve premiership success, then he may yet not retire as another Peter Pan.
Why don’t you just tie him down and pour alcohol down his throat, you “mature” brown paper bag?
Lol. Yeah I didn’t think Blitz was ready to be open minded about anything coming out of his (or any fark carlton player’s) mouth yet.
He’s spot on though. Fkg pertinent as Smithy would say.
If he doesn’t lift his game soon we might need a cannon
One more bad game and I’m changing my avatar.
Fark off Judd
Perfectly said. Well done Judd.
Is 100% right
The articles says nothing new, but it takes a long time to establish its basic premise.