If trading Parish is what it took to get Shiel, would you do it?
Hardly noticed him in the last few weeks, plays like he wasnt there.
Delist.
What did I do?
What else are we giving up and why would GWS do it? Even then why would we try to improve the midfield by removing one of our most talented up and coming midfielders? Because heās injured and no longer flavour of the month?
If you have a slight dip in form or are out of the team with injury you suddenly become trade bait on Blitz, while anyone whoās currently in form is unequivocally untradeable. As if short term form variations and current injuries are the primary factors in trade movements and list decisions.
You know what you did
Here we go again. I have been waiting to see who will be Bomberblitz new love child after Langford, and here we are. F##k this place is unreal.
Shiel(25)>Parish(21)
Iād imagine Shiel would cost our 1st pick + whatever we get from trading Parish (probs 1st ~10ish); and weād probably get a 2nd back
Trading for an established star who fits our age bracket and provides a point of difference in our midfield. Whilst Parish could get to Shielās level, it is far from a guarantee. So the question is then: Parish + our 1st > Shiel + a 2nd, Iād take that everyday.
In form today Noons.
You can make up trades that will never happen in your mind all day. Iāll just happily zone out
Itās basically the same deal that saw Collingwood land Treloar. The only reason the Giants are even considering trading Shiel is because they think theyāll lose home next year for at best a late 1st via FA compo.
FWIW I actually like Parish he is a gem, I just think Shiel is better, which he is at the moment. And everyone is tradeable, for the right price however high that may be.
It doesnāt even make sense.
Tell ya what - Iāll trade Nimo for Shiel.
No pablo espanol
This joint gets dumber by the week.
Do any of you b@stards work?! FMD.
So Parish could make his return this week? That was fast!
Well scanning this thread today is three minutes of my life Iāll never get back.
get to lunch break see 40 messages in parish threadā¦
get home, even moreā¦
Me, too.
At least it wasnāt 75 pun posts like it usually is.
Butā¦the second most frequent thingā¦Nino making stupid trade suggestions
Andā¦Killer_Mike hoeing into Parish, much as Ants hoes into Gleeson.