Thats harsh mate. Vety harsh. I’m actually trying to be objective instead of critical.
9-10 in a re-rated draft (3yrs on) is actually really good. Form, fitness, development all woukd be factors
1yr on I would probably have rated him 1.
I rate him highly.
And on the flip side its tough for high draft picks from an expectations point of view. McGrath for example can only maintain or slip down the track. Its not like a Hird situation where in hindsight he would have been much higher.