#32 - Ben McKay

so you don’t like the non support of an efc player, but then you go on to not support him by admitting he’s been no good lately, so by default you don’t admire your own view, cos if you truely wanted to support him, you’d pump him up, not admit to a truth.

or is blind support the only true support ?

He and I would have a simialr time then.

Except he gets hundreds of thousands of dollars a year and I dont.

There’s out of form - dropping a mark, losing a contest , poor decision errors - and then there’s something else. Over recent weeks, Ben has looked like he doesn’t want to go to the ball. There was a moment against Brisbane where the ball was bobbling at his feet and he couldn’t decide if he really wanted to pick it up. Like a cricketer that drops a catch or two and then hopes the ball doesn’t come anywhere near him. It’s a tough watch , and I hope he finds some clarity and composure of mind.

15 Likes

Hopefully he demands a trade to Hawthorn

You mean like Salmon. 30 years ago he was carrying an injury and attempted to play through it. Fans booed him and he ended up going to Hawthorn.

Ease up old fella - @Tids was simply saying the way Essendon fans boo or Bronx cheer our own players at actual matches is shthouse. And that’s correct.

Nothing about calling out poor form in conversation, at selection, or on a forum etc.

3 Likes

Big credit to Brad Scott on this one. Many thought there was no way he would consider dropping McKay.

McKay needed to go. Did go. Good. Take the opportunity to find the next player up.

1 Like

I’ve been that guy before, and man, is that a bad place to be mentally.

“Please don’t hit me a catch, please dont hit me a catch…” And sure enough, while that thought is flowing through your head, a catch will come your way.

8 Likes

That was pretty much my sporting life in general. :rofl:

3 Likes

Pretty stiff to get dropped after keeping his opponent goalless last week.

1 Like

One game in the reserves then back next week?

And he will probably pay in the forward line in VFL

He played on a first gamer. Not a massive achievement.

Harry is back in form which makes me think dropping Ben was a mistake.

1 Like

Thanks @Brewer_s_Droop.

I was a young fella at the West Coast game where big Fish copped the wrath of bombers fans and it made a lasting impression on me. I get that the footy is an outlet for people, an opportunity to vent all that pent up angst generated over the week. I just wish our supporter base wouldn’t funnel all their frustration towards the team into a single whipping boy. Stants was another who copped it unfairly IMO. I’d almost rather the English model of booing the whole team at the final siren, rather than bronxing a player during the game.

Id also note is not unique to Essendon supporters. Sitting with my wife’s StKilda supporting family in the 2000’s I would hear some extraordinary stuff directed at Raph Clarke.

Anyway, hope the boy goes well out of the spotlight. There’s a good redemption story available to him if he can get his head sorted.

5 Likes

All he has to do is try hard at playing football. Should take about 2 minutes to work out how to do that.

That the game he kicked 1.7, including a poster from 2m out? You could see he ws ■■■■■■■■ himself lining up by the end of the game. Think he kicked like 1.4 the week before or after as well.

I hated what our “supporters” did to Salmon. Was our best player pre 93, then wanted out shortly after.

3 Likes

That WC H&A 1993 MCG game was a pivotal moment in the season.

Ladder was bunched up.

Sheeds said in the doco that if we lose that game, he doesn’t believe we win the Flag that year.

His reaction after the final siren tells everything about its significance.

Salmon (who has a terrific sense of humour) said after receiving the free kick that a senior player was supportive (O’Donnell ?), and Mark Harvey was less supportive, threatening violence if he didn’t convert.

They then cut to Harvs who agreed with the above.

Edit…the booing game being referred to in the post you quoted was Week 1 Finals 1995.

5 Likes

Harry took some time off for personal reasons either just before or after Christmas

Fish kicked 1.4 against the Eagles. Followed it up with 1.7 the next week against the Blues.

Kicked 3.3 the week after and then went on a stretch of 11 goals without a miss over 4 games!

9 Likes