#32 - Ben McKay

Other than that we are great?

He needs a farking big preseason, learning how to not turn the football over.

I blame the players up the field why blokes like Mckay etc fumbled. Early in the season when we applied pressure up forward those fumbles weren’t happening.

the midfielders were the reason he handballed or kicked it to opposition players?

3 Likes

Come on Nino

No because the pressure they don’t apply the ball was living in our D50 for the second half of the year you could have Fletcher or Scarlet and they would make hand ball errors or kicks.

When our pressure was good those errors wern’t happening

IMO the defenders are handballing backwards because they’re just doing what theyre asked to by their coaches.

It’s no coincidence that midfielders are coached that way - handball backwards to the spare with time and then dispose - and our defensive line coach is a midfielder by trade.

Unfortunately our talent down there doesnt have the same level of composure as midfielders do in tight. McGrath and Heppell are the only ones who look competent at it all year… and even still its just the standard dump kick from McGrath…

It must be nice to be a defender.

Every mistake you make is the fault of the midfielders.

Not just the midfielders. it’s bloody hard to defend when the oppo move the ball c2c quicky under no pressure and lace out.

Was that even really happening as much this year?

And does that really mean that you lose the ability to handball?

It was especially in the second half of the year and mistakes happen

It’s unfortunate that the ability to have clean skills under pressure is necessary to be a good footballer.

2 Likes

Mackay disposal under absolutely no pressure is actually shithouse. You can’t pin it on pressure from the midfield. He’s a bit of a bonehead. He looks like he wants to dispose as quick as possible at all times, and half the time he barely gets a disposal out let alone to a target. It’s ridiculous.

1 Like

Just like how gws made some skills errors in the last qrt against Sydney

The swans would have beaten us soundly today. Momentum got GwS in the end. It’s hard having 3 fans. We would never have looked liked winning. No point comparing.

Only if the midfielders don’t do their job. If they do, then defenders can have terrible disposal and it doesn’t matter.

1 Like

Ah you see that wasn’t their fault. It was the players up the ground.

3 Likes

No if the back six have less pressure from the oppo then they would be able to execute better

Our skills seem to be fine if we are on top and dominating it’s when the oppo ramp up the pressure where our skills suffer

Fair enough Nino.

You could have just said “I like Ben McKay.”

I do