The suggestion is the younger end of age group guys have (after 8 or 10 years of it) formed a habit out of being the quieter/smaller/less developed one of the group by the time they hit 18.
Not sure if that holds up to scrutiny or not.
The fact the stats come from major league baseball, though, certainly make me more inclined to believe it. MLB development is certainly not like football. In most cases you get recruited from high school at 17-18 to go to college. Then after 1-4 years of college you get drafted (they do 40 rounds of draft picks). Then you play rookie league. If you’re any good at that level, you play short season A level. Then if you’re any good, you play single A. Then double A. Then triple A. If you go well there, you get a shot at the 25 strong major league roster.
It’s a huge, industrial scale process of whittling and funnelling, and the failure rate is bewildering.
All of which is to say, the stats they can produce on who is more or less likely to make it is extraordinary, especially compared to AFL where there’s ~80 new guys added in the whole league every year, and you’re half a chance of playing from round 1.
He was mostly following Stringer around in the first half which I’m sure was his assignment. You aren’t going to rack up big numbers when you have a run with role.
In the second half he played with more freedom and I thought he was good.
He needs to be allowed off the leash to produce his best footy.
At the moment I actually agree with you, but I think he is a unique sort who if he comes on in the midfield could be a really hard match up for opposition clubs.
It’s very difficult to judge based on todays hitout. Pretty scrappy game and he was playing on the weaker of the two sides playing mostly a negating role.
I suspect it’s all part of the training and as the year develops his role will take on more responsibility.
He’s definitely under different instructions around stoppages at VFL level.
At VFL level he is allowed freedom to hunt the ball which brings his best attributes into play which are his quick hands and also his ability to give himself space.
At AFL level he is always wrestling and concentrating far too much on his opponent. It’s either a confidence thing or he’s under instructions to play that way.
All the coaches continually say he is playing run with roles so I suspect he just playing the way he’s instructed.
We haven’t seen anything close to his best footy yet.