I don’t believe the rule is flawed.
I believe the apparent new interpretation of the rule is.
A kick or handball is not a bounce, and it’s madness to treat it like one.
2 Likes
I legit snorted.
If they tackle, the ball is not caught and therefore it’s holding the man.
If they don’t tackle, the ball is caught and they should have tackled them.
If it’s a GWS-GCS match and no one is watching, then the ball is Schrodingered and both caught and not caught at the time of the tackle.
3 Likes
He wasn’t marking his own kick though, he was making someone’s else kick which he flicked up with his foot
Basically, how I read that article is this:
- The AFL does not want a solo to be effectively the same as a bounce, in that your fifteen metres resets after either a bounce or a solo.
- The rules, as they stand, say a solo is like a bounce in this context. So the AFL have to fiddle around with ‘interpretation.’
- The AFL haven’t considered the wider implications of that interpretation. At all.
- gil.jpg
5 Likes
You called? Why?
1 Like
I actually cringe, and get angry when I see that pic
7 Likes
Gill is a carbon copy of Demetriou
2 Likes
Yes, yes, let the hate flow through you.
5 Likes
It was kicked in his direction and never hit the ground as it hit foot first and then hands.
It’s not like he kicked it and then ran down the field and marked it. He did have to go a metre or 2
(Just clarifying for everyone)
1 Like
So the AFL want to stop Conor from kicking to himself, but what I don’t understand is why.
The rule about bouncing is to increase the degree of difficulty of running with the ball. This is designed to stop one player grabbing the ball and running the length of the field, by making that more difficult via the requirement to bounce.
Isn’t the chip kick even more difficult to pull off than a bounce? So why should it be discouraged?
Imaging Conor running towards the 50 metre line with the ball. Two opposition players running towards him from the other direction to try and lay the tackle. As opposed to trying to run around them, Conor simply chips the ball over their heads, runs straight past them, catches his own ball and strolls into an open goal. Wouldn’t that be legitimately exciting? Why would the AFL want to legislate against that?
8 Likes
I think DJR might be able to answer that question for you…
9 Likes
You can do it this time, Wim.
Because you could just tap it on your foot, rugby style which would be way easier.
Irish Bomber finds new loyalty down under
Callum Twomey
Mar 20, 2018 7:00AM
Sometimes you wake up and see a video from back home and you miss it and wish you were there
IN IRELAND’s Gaelic competition, players very rarely switch clubs. They join the county side that is most local to them, where they’ve grown up, and stay there for the rest of their careers.
“Wherever you’re born you play for,” explains Conor McKenna, who left Ireland aged 18 to pursue an AFL career with Essendon.
"Basically back home it’s like if you are born in Essendon, you play for Essendon. If you are born in North Melbourne, that’s where you play.
"It’s all about that culture, and no matter if you’re the worst team or the best team, you just play for that side.
Conor McKenna has overcome homesickness to thrive with the Dons -
“You can be traded, but it’s very, very rare unless people have a job two or three hours from their home place. It’s more about playing for the pride of where you’re from.”
Being a league of amateurs – players still have day jobs while they play at the top level in Ireland – makes this more understandable. But it also underlines how McKenna was faced with a new dilemma at the end of last season, when rival clubs came hunting for the dashing Bombers half-back as he remained out of contract.
Brisbane offered a lucrative long-term deal and the Lions weren’t the only ones to show their interest. But Essendon came to the party with a four-year deal tying McKenna to the club until the end of 2021, and the 21-year-old agreed to it.
“Most Irish boys here stay with the same team. Maybe some players chase success, but I think we’ll get success at Essendon so I’m happy,” he told AFL.com.au on the eve of his fourth season.
"I didn’t really talk much about the contract during last year, I wanted to concentrate on my football and not have any of that business taking my mind off it. I got to my last two games and started to get seriously talking. My manager said they’d offered a four-year deal, and I signed it.
“I never wanted to leave. I’ve been here for three years and for me to go somewhere else it would have meant, although I wasn’t starting playing again, I would have had to meet new people, make new friends. It would have been a big change. I was always happy to stay at Essendon.”
It’s easy to see why McKenna had suitors. He’s what clubs are searching for in their attacking backmen: he’s fast, he loves to run and carry and he’s a terrific kick.
Last season he played 19 games and averaged 17 touches, but McKenna still didn’t feel settled. This year, after a pre-season interrupted slightly by an ankle injury he suffered preparing for the International Rules Series, he has a clear idea of how to improve again.
“I really want to get to that consistent level where you know what you’re going to get from me every week. That’s where every player wants to get to and what we want as a team, so everyone knows they can look at me and know what I’m going to be able to give,” he said.
“You can’t just stop now with one good year behind you.”
McKenna’s has been a swift rise. In April, 2014, he played with the European Legion (a side made up of players of different ages from across Europe) in London in a game against the touring national Academy squad of draft prospects for that year.
Against the likes of Christian Petracca, Isaac Heeney and Lachie Weller, McKenna starred with four goals.
He had spoken to a couple of AFL clubs, including Essendon, before that day about a possible AFL career after showing his talents playing for Tyrone county. That night, several more recruiters introduced themselves to gauge his interest.
Six months later, he was officially a Bomber and another 10 months after that, he made his debut for Essendon against Richmond in round 22, 2015, kicking a goal with his first touch.
McKenna looks back on that game in London – his first ever – with some fondness as the beginning of a whirlwind.
“When you don’t understand the game you just go out and play it with no fear and do whatever you can with the ball and that’s what I did. I tried to play Gaelic with an AFL ball,” he said.
"It’s gone very quick. The first two years felt a bit slower and I was a bit homesick, but that’s the main thing for Irish players – get over that and it becomes a lot easier.
“You have good days and bad days, and sometimes you wake up and see a video from back home and you miss it and wish you were there. But I have committed here now. It’s my decision and if I didn’t want to be here, I wouldn’t be.”
McKenna’s brother and his girlfriend have moved to Melbourne, and he’s looking forward to moving in with them soon to counter his lack of family in Australia.
He still plans on one day heading back to play for Tyrone in the Gaelic competition – “… to win a premiership here and then one at home is the dream,” he says – but until then the Bombers have his full devotion.
However, he’ll always have his Gaelic background running through his game, which was on show against Richmond in the JLT Community Series when McKenna twice kicked the ball to himself while running around an opponent.
“It’s called a ‘solo’ back home, and you have to do one every four steps in Gaelic. I went to kick the ball and saw someone about to block it, so at last moment decided to pull it back. It worked the first time,” he said.
“The second time I did it, I don’t know what I was thinking there.”
9 Likes
I’m excited by just how good Irish can become.
1 Like
He’s young, turns 22 in a week’s time. And his speed and creativity gives him that x-factor.
6 Likes
If they remove the “solo” because it’s not considered a kick, then they should remove the out on the full rule where the ball hasn’t travelled the required distance.
You can touch the ball on the ground too. That’s just as easy. Pretty hard running full speed then lifting a leg to touch the ball.
it’s not that hard
8 Likes