It’s a pretty reasonable take to be honest.
McMahon is a multiple goal kicker week in week out and so far Gerreyn has shown a few glimpses
1 Like
Gerryn is a first year 19 year old who played ruck in juniors learning his craft as a key forward. McMahon is 23 and at his third club. Of course McMahon is better now! Happy to take a better with anyone about who has the longer career.
1 Like
Hes also injured
Absolutely, and last year he was very average and even his games this year well shocking.
Only kicked 2 today, I hope we aren’t Essington-ing him already… but still kicking goals which is great. Just can’t see him coming in, esp after May kicked 3.
McMahon was pretty invisible.
He may win Mark of the Year, though.
For a club that struggles to kick enough goals, I’d find it pretty ridiculous if he doesn’t get a chance either this season or next.
A delisting without being trialled would be really stupid
3 Likes
Average ? 40 odd goals ?
Voss kicked bulk goals in the VFL and never got a go.
I suspect he does eventually get some AFL games, but it wouldn’t exactly be unprecedented if he didn’t.
1 Like
*Stole
I don’t care if we never play him, we made FARK CARLTON just a bit weaker on some level.
For that he gets life membership
3 Likes
I thought I read somewhere that McMahon was only on a 6 month contract which would mean he needs to get some games soon. Took a great mark yesterday and obviously has some tricks. Needs a chance in the seniors to show his stuff.
1 Like
He’s not getting in the seniors while wright, caddy and may are fit and firing
2 Likes
Or show enough in the VFL and on the track, I guess?
I’d also be surprised if no other team was interested, even as a backup FF option.
Just has to wait for another tall forward to be injured
Probably won’t be too long……
1 Like
Is it just McMahon and Unwin yet to debut? If so get them in and lets have a look.
Nguyen. Gerreyn.
5 Likes
Thanks, play them as well.
I agree it should happen but I can’t remember us EVER aggressively moving a player on.
Monfries & Melksham are the only two that get even close, but they’d both plateaued, both were tapped up rather than shopped, and each had a carrot, Monfries ostensibly for “more midfield time” and Melk for a 4-year deal for more money than our 2-year offer.
1 Like
I know we don’t wanna stuff up our structure, but might be time to bring in a guy that can kick goals.
2 Likes