Yep Reynolds had a bit of talent, hell you have to to make it into the afl.
think he like a few guys around that time were poorly developed due to unfortunately the club as a whole sliding down the ladder from 02 onwards and sheedy trying to hang onto the glory days with players who were past their prime.
then he just lost all confidence, and could never get it back.
Ironically if memory serves me correctly, he followed a similar path to Daniher, up until daniher took off this year ( minus the goals for reynolds)
I seem to recall alot of people questioning daniher last year and would he ever make it.
that he’s a dumb footballer cos sheedy said so, cos he wasn’t kicking goals and his action was putrid.
The difference being Reynolds could never turn the corner and re capture his best form. Daniher has this year, and looks a totally different player, to the point where people are saying what they are now.
not saying reynolds could have been a star, but he was a decent player who IMO just wasn’t developed properly and never given a proper chance to succeed.