Best 22 in 2014

After the trade period this is what our best 22 looks like to me:

 

FB          Baguley     Carlisle     Fletcher

HB          Hibberd     Hooker     Dempsey

  C          Heppell      Watson     Goddard

HF          Kommer    Hurley       Winderlich

FF          Chapman  Daniher     Bellchambers

 

R            Ryder     Hocking     Stanton

 

Int           Zaharakis, Myers, Howlett, Merrett

Where's Edwards?

How long until someone puts Garlett in that team?

That was quick.

Where's Edwards?

Edwards would be fighting for a spot with Kavanagh, Hams, Browne, Dalgleish, Ashby, Aylett, O'Brien.

 

There's 6-7 midfielder types who will be our next gen midfield following the Jobe-Stanton-Goddard era - just need to get a really good inside mid/clearance machine.  Whether by accident or design, this is an excellent list demographic to have.

 

Our list is shaping up very well - clearly now need to start adding some KP types and a ruck over the next 1-3 years.

After the trade period this is what our best 22 looks like to me:

 

FB          Baguley     Carlisle     Fletcher

HB          Hibberd     Hooker     Dempsey

  C          Heppell      Watson     Goddard

HF          Kommer    Hurley       Winderlich

FF          Chapman  Daniher     Bellchambers

 

R            Ryder     Hocking     Stanton

 

Int           Zaharakis, Myers, Howlett, Merrett

Unbelievably left out Melksham - put him in for Kommer

Using Baker's model as the basis of my team ...

 

FB Baguley Carlisle Fletcher

HB Hibberd Hooker Dempsey

C Heppell Watson Goddard

HF Kommer Hurley Melksham Winderlich

FF Chapman Daniher Bellchambers

 

R Ryder Hocking Stanton

 

Int Zaharakis, Myers, Howlett, Dalgleish

 

You'll notice I cleverly managed to find room for Melk ....

 

After the trade period this is what our best 22 looks like to me:

 

FB          Baguley     Carlisle     Fletcher

HB          Hibberd     Hooker     Dempsey

  C          Heppell      Watson     Goddard

HF          Kommer    Hurley       Winderlich

FF          Chapman  Daniher     Bellchambers

 

R            Ryder     Hocking     Stanton

 

Int           Zaharakis, Myers, Howlett, Merrett

Unbelievably left out Melksham - put him in for Kommer

 

yeah i was about to pull you up on that,

 

hepp starts in the square for mine and if we want a runner starting in the square it should be zaha. i still hold out hope that we are going to flip hurls and jake c

 

bags hurls fletch

hibb hooker demps

 

stanton watson bj

ryder hepp hocking

 

zaha jd melk

chappy carlisle licha

 

tbell howlett kommer

 

myers

B: Fletcher Carlisle Baguley

HB: Dempsey Hooker Hibberd

C: Stanton Watson Zaharakis

HF: Goddard Hurley Chapman

F: Winderlich Daniher Bellchambers

R: Ryder Hocking Heppell

 

I/C: Melksham, Myers, Howlett, Kommer

 

Emg: Pears, Colyer, Merrett, Kavanagh, etc

Using Baker's model as the basis of my team ...

 

FB Baguley Carlisle Fletcher

HB Hibberd Hooker Dempsey

C Heppell Watson Goddard

HF Kommer Hurley Melksham Winderlich

FF Chapman Daniher Bellchambers

 

R Ryder Hocking Stanton

 

Int Zaharakis, Myers, Howlett, Dalgleish

 

You'll notice I cleverly managed to find room for Melk ....

Genius!

I like this game, it makes me think that the season is abou tto start. think I will go home and watch my 1993 GF DVD.

 

My turn

 

B:     Baguley      Hurley     Fletcher

HB:  Dempsey    Hooker    Hibberd

C:    Goddard     Watson    Heppell

HF:   Kommer    Carlisle    Myers

F:     Winderlich  Daniher   Chapman

R:     Ryder         Hocking   Melksham

 

I/C: Bellchambers  Howlett   Zaharakis   Stanton

Melk off hff? Are you joking needs to be in the guts to belt ■■■■■

Now is a good time to remember that Melksham is suspended for not one but two weeks. ■■■■■■■ bullshit that was.

Is this for real?

sadly yes, the "but he head butted my arm defense" fell apart when the mrp ruled it was unreasonable for melk to have arms.

Not enough Aylett. Gun.

if Kommer is in our best 22 then we are struggling, Merrett is the future I can see similarites to Caracella early in his career.  Fletcher plays 10-15 games, (3 weeks for a tripping suspension mid year) and Pears plays the rest at back pocket. Wouldn't mind seeing Steinberg or Van Unen pushing Pears for the Fletcher spot

 

B:     Baguley      Hurley     Fletcher/Pears

HB:  Dempsey    Hooker     Hibberd

C:    Stanton       Watson    Zaharakis

HF:  Goddard     Carlisle    Merrett

F:     Winderlich  Daniher   Chapman

R:     Ryder         Heppell   Melksham

 

I/C: Bellchambers  Howlett   Hocking Myers

 

After the trade period this is what our best 22 looks like to me:

 

FB          Baguley     Carlisle     Fletcher

HB          Hibberd     Hooker     Dempsey

  C          Heppell      Watson     Goddard

HF          Kommer    Hurley       Winderlich

FF          Chapman  Daniher     Bellchambers

 

R            Ryder     Hocking     Stanton

 

Int           Zaharakis, Myers, Howlett, Merrett

Unbelievably left out Melksham - put him in for Kommer

 

 

Would put Melksham in over Howlett IMO. Leave Kommer in.

if Kommer is in our best 22 then we are struggling, Merrett is the future I can see similarites to Caracella early in his career.  Fletcher plays 10-15 games, (3 weeks for a tripping suspension mid year) and Pears plays the rest at back pocket. Wouldn't mind seeing Steinberg or Van Unen pushing Pears for the Fletcher spot

 

B:     Baguley      Hurley     Fletcher/Pears

HB:  Dempsey    Hooker     Hibberd

C:    Stanton       Watson    Zaharakis

HF:  Goddard     Carlisle    Merrett

F:     Winderlich  Daniher   Chapman

R:     Ryder         Heppell   Melksham

 

I/C: Bellchambers  Howlett   Hocking Myers

I agree with this, but Zacka and Goddard switched.

if Kommer is in our best 22 then we are struggling, Merrett is the future I can see similarites to Caracella early in his career. Fletcher plays 10-15 games, (3 weeks for a tripping suspension mid year) and Pears plays the rest at back pocket. Wouldn't mind seeing Steinberg or Van Unen pushing Pears for the Fletcher spot
B: Baguley Hurley Fletcher/Pears
HB: Dempsey Hooker Hibberd
C: Stanton Watson Zaharakis
HF: Goddard Carlisle Merrett
F: Winderlich Daniher Chapman
R: Ryder Heppell Melksham
I/C: Bellchambers Howlett Hocking Myers


Kommer was best 22 all year. Including when we were 2nd on the ladder.
And Hurley ain't playing defence. Not now.