I’ve just finished listening to The Running Grave by Robert Galbraith (aka J K Rowling), seventh in the series of Cormoran Strike detective novels. I’ve listened to them all. They’re pretty popular – when a new one comes out it gets a prime position in the bookshop, and the audiobook appears virtually simultaneously.
They’re not very good. I’m not going to bother with any more. Okay, they’re all page-turners. Something about her writing always makes you want to know what’s going to happen next, and I fully accept that that’s an attribute highly to be prized in any author’s work. But really, as regards the basic plot, the characterisation and the writing style, they’re not very good and this one was really pretty poor.
It’s also far too long. The first in the series was 15 hours long as an audiobook, which is a solid length for a novel, but the same thing happened with these novels as happened with her Harry Potters (which I’ve never read): as the series went on, the books got longer and longer, and the seventh is 34 hours, which is immense. A lot of it was pretty tedious, too, although never quite tedious enough to make me give up. (I rarely give up once started.)
The setup is that Cormoran Strike is an ex-military policeman who was blown up in Iraq and lost half a leg, so he left the army and set up as a private detective. He’s the son of a rich and famous pop singer whom he hates for having abandoned him as a child; his mother was a hopeless hippie/bohemian type who bounced from one no-hoper man to another and brought up Strike and his sister in a succession of squats and other squalid places. At the beginning of the first book he hires a temp, Robyn Ellacott, who quickly becomes a detective and before much longer his business partner. There’s a continuing theme through the books of a romance between Strike and Robyn, but as of the end of book 7 it’s yet to burst into flower and is frankly rather boring.
Book 7 is about the attempt to rescue the client’s son from the clutches of a religious cult. It has every single trope you could possibly imagine: brainwashing, mystical incantations, sexual abuse, other physical abuse, economic exploitation, and of course (it’s a detective novel), a couple of murders, fraud and even child trafficking. There’s a long – very very long – section where Robyn goes undercover as a convert to the cult that gets more unbelievable with each passing page. It’s all very politically correct, too.
JK Rowling is said to be worth well over $1 billion, so she obviously knows how to write books that sell. I rather admire her for writing the first of the Strike books and getting it published without revealing that she was “Robert Galbraith”, but that doesn’t make her any better as a writer.
Don’t bother.