Brad Scott - Poll says hated more than Fark Carlton (Part 3)

I think Brad is going all out to win games, he is just too stupid to not select the right match ups to give the team the best chance at a win

You don’t select guys like Shiel and Setterfield if it’s a development year

You don’t keep on selecting SEH as sub if you are all about development

13 Likes

I don’t care if we limp over the line against west coast while giving the kids opportunities. But want I can’t stand is limping over the line playing the senior guys who won’t be here much longer.

We need to get continuity into the squad and have these guys playing 2-3 years together

what i don’t understand is, he comes in and proclaims defensive pressure is key.

yet defensive aspects of the game, 3 years in are still the worst aspect of the club.

How you can have a 3 on 1 on the goaline, WC win a free kick and roll down the ground and score a goal without an essendon player near their opponent throughout the play.

how the ■■■■ can you have a number disparage in your forwardline, then allow it all the way own the ground ?

how is defensive setup, zoning, gameplan all of it still so trash 3 years in ?

you aren’t “finding” out about anyone now, now it’s a pattern, a habit and a trait.

i’ve seen better defending by blind, dear monks, with no arms or legs, what the actual ■■■■ do they do/teach with regard to defending ? surely it can not be to just allow multiple opposition players to just do whatever the ■■■■ they want, and hope they ■■■■ it up and turn it over.

5 Likes

Untitled
I have more faith in this guy being able to defend, moreso than 3/4’s of our ■■■■■■■ side.

1 Like

We seriously had to talk Brad out of a desk job at AFL land to coach us. Is it any wonder he’s as ■■■■ as he is?

1 Like

Wait, you’ve actually seen that?

Farkin cool.

5 Likes

After how we treated Rutten that would have put a lot of applicants off at applying for the job Hird was basically the only person who was putting his hand up

Not even the greatest coach of the modern in Clarkson wanted a bar of us picked North over Essendon.

1 Like

What senior guys are we playing who wont be here much longer? Shiel?

Shiel or Setterfield over Tsatas is the one I am referring too (unless the club doesn’t rate Tsatas and looks to move him at the end of the year).

Previous years we’ve had Goldy over Bryan, Weideman over Hayes, Kelly over Massimo

1 Like

You could be right.

I don’t know for certain, but I think the contract extension and the clear out of older players at the end of last year seems more like what you’d do if you were trying to have a development year. And I don’t know enough about how he thinks to know if he prefers players to fight their way through a tough matchup for a period of time.

It seems to me that everyone here wants us to develop, and win all our games like fully developed champions.

Also, Buckley had publicly said he wouldn’t take the job, if offered, as it was too politically charged, and there was too much to fix.

1 Like

We are actually lucky to even get Brad to coach us. He could have easly told Essendon no thanks I’m happy with my job at the AFL

1 Like

We’re so lucky.

Before each game, the bomber fans should light a candle for Brad, and hold up banners that say ‘thank you brad.’

26 Likes

I watched Gold Coast and Giants built from scratch.

One team played all youngsters, and hasn’t been competitive until this season.

The other team had a few experienced players amongst the youngsters, and those youngsters developed much more quickly.

It seems to me, that’s the development standard. Youngsters in amongst decent older players.

1 Like

I’m just pointing out the facts

Such a selfless man, Brad. $1 million a year for the past 2 years getting us to 11th. Then gets himself a nice one year extension.

Nino is right. Brad didn’t have to accept that one year extension, but we are lucky he did

4 Likes

The only thing anyone will be lighting is their pitch forks.

We’re getting some natural improvement (being generous) from a couple of young players and literally ■■■■ all else.

He’s useless.

The facts, you reckon?

Ok Nino.

Who do you want as coach then?

When things aren’t going well, everyone’s a critic.

For those that want Brad gone now, what’s the solution?

What actually transforms us into a contender?