Brad Scott - yeah, whatever (Part 3)

Yep i was there too i think from memory didnt Hocking have a crack at Lecrae?

5 Likes

Slattery didn’t play in that game.

1 Like

Forgot about the ben mckinley game whcih was under knights too, good lord

No he didn’t, Slattery didn’t even play.

Heath Hocking, Courtenay Dempsey, Dustin Fletcher and Mark McVeigh played on him.

7 Likes

Yeah you’re right.

It was Hocking.

Which makes it even worse.

1 Like

He tried 4 players including the great Fletcher.

2 Likes

I’m not old enough and was too late of a footy bloomer to understand the last 100 posts and coaches from 20 years ago.

I look forward to 10+ years from now when I can join in on decades past ā– ā– ā– ā–  talking about the period post mid-2010s though.

4 Likes

When you look at that team selection, defending didn’t look a priority. Baz ball was all Knights had.

1 Like

2 Likes

Knights’ coaching or your memory?

Hardwicks laptop cost us big time

Hardwick’s laptop saved his legacy.

5 Likes

True probably would have been sacked in his 3rd year :smile:

1 Like

There’s no way Hardwick or any other coach was going to turn dodo’s duds into a premiership list. If its true that Hardwick was very critical of our list at the time he was interviewed then it can’t be discounted that it played a part in the clubs decisions. Did we really not hire Hardwick because of his laptop or did his judgement of the clubs position not align with the boards delusions? Remember we sacked Sheedy under the pretence that he wasn’t getting the best out of the list so a new prospective coach telling the club it was years off contending might have gone against him.

6 Likes

We should all go gentle on Matthew Knights here. The past is the past and he needs all\ the help he can get now.

This is pure speculation of course but if it’s true that Hardwick was critical of the list then there’s a fair chance Dodoro and he’s henchmen would have stopped any chance of hiring him, we have seen what has happened to multiple employees who were critical of Dodoro and the list

5 Likes

The board / club wouldn’t have picked a coach who wanted to gut the list.
Not after five years of hearing Sheedy say they were ā€˜one jet midfielder’ away.

Knights prioritised younger players and still got torched for it when it came to moving with the times and pushing past the remnants of the 2000 team (Fletcher, Lloyd, JJ, Lucas, etc).
Hardwick would have gotten more out of the team, but still not good enough to hang on to his job. Imagine going through 3 years of prioritising youth slowly improving, then sitting through 3 losing elimination finals and then having a seventh year stinker with a crushing 100+ loss to Sydney in round 23.

I’m sure the club and supporters would hold long enough to let him get to an eighth season to see us win a premiership…

1 Like

No chance he would have been lucky to last three years with us

1 Like

It was all on Jackson, he gutted the Club and worked to undermine Sheedy. Hope he has constant haemorrhoids.

2 Likes

And what motive would he have to do that ?