Actually, that’s the reason you get him, not the reason you don’t.
Gibbs isn’t really a squib per se, that is more there Murphy trait, he is outside runner. he can go in and win his own ball though.
Again, 2 years ago maybe, but not now. Also he will go to South Australia when he leaves Carlscum.
Of course you would.
He’s way better than most are giving him credit for. Would be same age as Goddard when we got him and you would expect 4 good years from him. Is never going to happen and trade would need to be fair, but you don’t turn down that kind of player.
But ■■■■ Carlton.
2 Likes
You may have to be a bit clearer, because for a minute there I thought you were favourably comparing Gibbs to Goddard…
He compared age. W T F
Either way, your a idiot if you don’t rate Gibbs. He’s a very good player. But yes, he’s no Goddard 
1 Like
Probably because he has committed to the crows, but we could do worse.
Can play, but won’t come cheap.
If we suddenly became the South Adelaide Bombers, I’d be all for it, but we’ll cross that bridge when we get to it.
If you ever hear someone say “I want to go to Adelaide” know that it’s just a cry for help.
3 Likes
Why?