Changes vs Port - Round 3

I’m sure you have a “mate” that’s keen. You can be open on this site if you need to be. We’re all accepting.

Since the majority of our players should be well-rested from playing sweetfa against the crows, I’m looking forward to Thursday. We play in a cosy stadium, which is an added plus. I’m hopeful :shushing_face:

You know, you can get something similar at the shops.

Start casting an eye on Gerreyn Scott and get your head out of your arrse. Might not be quite ready yet but shows a lot of promise.

OUT: Shiel, Jones, Prior, Menzie
IN: El-Hawli, Ridley, Hayes, Davey (sub)

Never again: Shiel, Jones on a wing

2 Likes

Agree with this. Cricket selectors do it all the time by persisting with out of form guys rather than giving them a chance to find form at the lower level.

Every training report in here had McKay either not there at all recovering from surgery, or doing basic jogging or handball drills in the modified list. That’s not a preseason, that’s designed to lead into a fitness program and introduction for a few rounds in the VFL before going up to the afl. It’s like they feel he has to play to amortise his yearly cost. Just play Hayes for a while and let McKay find his feet.

4 Likes

all is forgiven if he belts willie rioli. ■■■■ that guy

So many teams have looked dogsh!t 1 week then great the next. Collingwood, Saints, Port, Richmond. Surely it will happen for Essendon? right? right?

5 Likes

Would love to know ports average winning margin against us at marvel. Feels like they belt us by 50+ every time. They might break some records this week

We will be lucky to get 20k in attendance

At least I might have the whole row to myself to stretch out and relax in

3 Likes

There needs to be hard questions asked of Brad at the next presser. Why persist with Jones on a wing when he gets 7-10 possessions, can’t chase, has low footy IQ, and is too slow for that position. It’s complete madness. Surely Saad is a much better wingman already

2 Likes

My grandmother is a better wingman than Jones, she is 94 and has one arm

5 Likes

Out: anyone
In: this guy

3 Likes

Saad has been average on the wing in the VFL, Lual being better.
Clarke was outstanding yesterday in the backline.
An alternative would be

Jones forward where we need more height (or the Big G)
Roberts wing
Clarke back flank.

It does seem weird to consider playing them in their actual positions though.

2 Likes

We need a defence structure

Caddy has shown a bit more that Reid in his 12 games I reckon.

Can she kick? Don’t expect she is that quick though, but maybe quicker than a few we have running around.

1 Like

Sheil out, Ridley in
Reid out, Hayes in

Its got 10 goal loss infront of an empty Marvel Stadium written all over it.

4 Likes

The crowd numbers will tell the club what we think.

The same blokes let us down every week but are undroppable, Shiel, McGrath, Perkins, Jones, McKay so what is the use of suggesting changes? Scott refuses to make changes because he is bull headed. The only change that will happen will be Ridley in for someone. Who ever the someone is, who knows?

1 Like