I still want to know whether weâre playing this in 2000 or 2019.
In any case, I find the idea of dropping the enforcer from the team with the most successful season of all time for a role-playing plodder that canât beat 18th quite risible.
I reckon Wallisâ influence as an enforcer was and is grossly overstated. There were tougher players in the back line alone like Solomon, MJ and Hardwick.
Wallis was a role playing plodder who averaged 8 games a year over 15 seasons. And I think he was gifted plenty of those games over more deserving players.
As the years go by the myth of Wallis as this feared brute grows, and the memories of the baths he was given by a host of players fade.
Still canât believe people would pick this bloke over 2 All Australians.
Thereâs literally 3 videos of him playing on YouTube and this is 2 of them.
I have.
Wallisâs combined contribution was to clean up Hana and a 19 y/old Brad Green.
I doubt thereâs a coach in AFL history thatâs picking him over either Hurley or Hooker.
And his stats in the â00 prelim?
1 kick, 1 handball, 1 tackle, a single 1%er and 2 frees against
I remember him as plenty tough - but that was just about all he had going for him.
Canât imagine any coach picking him over Hurley or Hooker, under any circumstances.
He was a role player who happened to play in 2 flags. Good effort.
I remember he played on Carey in a pre season game once. He won the fights quite convincingly (which is no small feat, mind you) but Carey still kicked 6, potentially in a half.
Iâm fairness, Wallisâ 2000 season was pretty damn good, many levels above anything else he did in any other year of his career. If the selection criteria here is based purely on that season, he probably gets a game in front of Ambrose.
Iâm arguing specifically against Ambrose.
Hooker is fantastic, no argument there.
Would you have him and Fletcher? Donât know.
And if itâs either or then itâs no contest.
I personally wouldnât have Hurley over Wallis.
Hurley is clearly the better player but simply doesnât have the presence that Wallis brought to that team.
Again, I suggest you watch those Grand Finals.
So I concede there are points for the other two, but Ambrose is just absolute farking nonsense.