It's the cool thing to do these days but I blame Moffatt. I don't think he's the right guy for running the show. As a writer he's fine, so find someone new and keep him on writing a couple of episodes a year.
He has written some great episodes, including close to my favourite but I tend to agree. However Davies was definitely tired by the end of his run and my problems with the show began then. Karen Gillan distracted my critical eye for a time.
My problem is this, and it may sound silly given the nature of the show but I don't buy the emotional drama anymore. It's a bit Star Trek: Voyager-ish.
I feel like I need to see a Blake's 7 style final scene in order to believe again.