Essendon vs Carlton - Votes

3 Shiel
2 Laverde
1 Perkins

3 Shiel
2 Perkins
1 Hind

Were you in the bar or watching the game? Just checking your level of observation.

Yes and I observed us only kick 4 goals after 1/4 time

1 Like

And blues kicked 3 from half time.
We were not great but we were not outclassed by a top four team

3 Shiel
2 Draper
1 Hobbs

how did Stringer miss?

2 Likes

3 - Shiel
2 - Hind
1 - Ridley

Draper, Perkins & Hobbs all had their moments. Caldwell a strong second half.

STRINGER
CULTER
HEPP

Not vote worthy. Sorry, but Not one player won their position. And not one was worthy of votes. Really disappointing.

1 Like

We were utterly outclassed. Some of the football played by Essendon tonight was amateurish. Carlton put the cue away in the last quarter and we still failed to score.

We are so bad it’s just hard to see where the next win will come from.

Rutten may not be the issue but this game plan, if you can call it that, is a putrid mess.

2 Likes

Rids
Draper
Shiel

Scoreboard clap clap clap

I can’t think of a single player who deserves a vote.

1 Like

Brasher special mention!

Actual votes for me

3 - Shiel
2 - Hind
1 - Draper

3 Ridley
2 Shiel
1 Hind

3 Shiel - Best game I have seen him play

2 Ridley - His best game of year

1 Hind -Tried hard all game

Merrett was OK, Jones looked great early on as did Draper.

Hobbs, Caldwell and Martin were average, Durham and Perkins were below average.

Kelly, Cutler, Heppell and Jake were poor. Jake will improve, the rest will not.

Shiel
Lav
Hobbs

3 Hind
2 Shiel
1 Perkins

Perko
Hobbs
Lav