I’m with those that feel Phillips is out and it’s either Bryan or Voss in.
I think Bryan will get the nod.
However, I cannot stress enough how much better I think Voss makes our side purely because of his aggression.
I’m with those that feel Phillips is out and it’s either Bryan or Voss in.
I think Bryan will get the nod.
However, I cannot stress enough how much better I think Voss makes our side purely because of his aggression.
Of course. This side really needs some bigger bodies.
I think Bryan plays for his tap ruckwork.
Love Draper but his tap work often goes to opposition. He evens the ledger with brute force knocks fwd etc.
Bryan is only not our 1st ruck IMO because at senior level he is yet to prove he is fit enough to get to enough contests.
Given he’s had more development i hope he makes me eat my words about getting to contests.
He will get better at marking with experience and growth and become something like English
Both Draper and Bryan are great centre bounce Ruckman, but poor/average around the ground and boundary throw ins.
Which is why Phillips is still in the side.
Phillips is not giving us anything around the ground right now. He has been right out of form. Bryan could not do any worse but he might do it lot better.
Madness. Pure madness.
Both Draper and Bryan are great centre bounce Ruckman, but poor/average around the ground and boundary throw ins.
I think Draper has improved this area a lot this year, he is taking marks in defense more than ever this year.
BRING
Where’s the team, Smythy?
don’t let me down essendon
BRING
HIM
aformato:I would have played Voss over Phillips weeks ago, however Bryan’s form now is too hard to ignore. If Bryan doesn’t get his chance in the team now he may never will.
The issue that you have with Bryan, is that he simply cannot play forward.
He is an out & out ruckman. So your either playing him mainly in the ruck, and Draper is playing as a Key Forward.
Or Bryan is sitting on the bench for 40-50% of the game.
I think Pauls Cousins has said its not that he can’t play forward and take a mark, he just hasn’t had the opportunity this year with him pretty much being the solo VFL ruck and believes he’s been working on his forward craft at training.
FWIW I’d love to see both Voss and Bryan in, unsure how that would look though.
announce
Houli_Dooli:BRING
HIM
Grapes & Palm Fronds
Voss going on a journey into the unknown in WA could make an interesting story.
Any loud cheering coming from Tulla yet ?
IT’S TIME
Yes, but only because Blake Caracella brought Cornetto’s for all the boys to celebrate beating Richmond.