Okay...
I'll play...
We need a dangerous goal scoring small forward. Kommer has been great but he strikes me as a better defensive forward. Alwiyn Davey is depth at best. I know there are many fans of his, but I'd love to get Yarran, Lachie Neale, Hayden Crozier or someone like Ben Kennedy.
I think we need another inside midfielder that demands the oppositions attention. This will enable Myers to shift onto the forward flank. Melksham should develop further and become a pretty decent midfielder.
We need another outside midfielder to help with our rotation. I like Heath Hocking. I think he does his job, but we probably need to develop Melksham more in a tagger role and free up a spot in the midfield. Heath Hocking would be a good depth option.
We need a better small defender. Baguley has been good, but I really worry about his skill level. He's a confidence player so when we aren't playing well, he is just as likely to give the ball back to the opposition as he is to giving it to us. A Marley Williams type would be absolutely perfect for us. Very good defender, neat foot skills, good decision making and willing to play for the hard ball.
We need a good solid mid sized defender. Fletcher is our best one and he's edging closer to retirement. Tayte Pears has played the mid sized defender and I don't think he's the prototypical defender we need. Kyle Hardingham is good depth, but I doubt he can be reliable.
As far as players who should continue to develop nicely, I'd say Merrett is looming as our next big thing outside of Joey D.
I'd say it'll take a few years to gather options for the above (by trading, drafting and free agency) and I'd wager that by that time, Jobe Watson and Goddard will be nearing towards the end of their careers and begin having less and less impact on a game. We'd need to find replacements internally (Kav and maybe another) and also need to add three or four depth type players who can be relied upon in the event of injury.
In all fairness, I'd say in three years time we could be right within winning a flag. Two if we trade aggressively (Gumby, Pears, Jetta might be of use to other teams), pick up a few good value free agents and draft wisely.