Nothing better to do today, so I compared BB Nobby Clarke Award vs the other one. Matches OK except no love from maggots for Jake Melksham. Posted it as a table but didn't work, so first votes in each round are for Brownlow and the 5 to 1 are for the Nobby.
Round 1
Adelaide 11.16 (82) Essendon 18.9 (117) at AS
3. B Howlett (Ess)
2. J Watson (Ess)
1. H Hocking (Ess
5. Jobe Watson
4. Ben Howlett
3. Heath Hocking
2. Courtenay Dempsey
1. Jake Carlisle
Round 2
Essendon 28.16 (184) Melbourne 5.6 (36) at MCG
3. D. Heppell (Ess)
2. J. Watson (Ess)
1. B. Stanton (Ess)
5. Jobe Watson
4. Dyson Heppell
3. Tom Bellchambers
2. Patrick Ryder
1. Stewart Crameri
Round 3
Fremantle 9.14 (68) Essendon 10.12 (72) at PS
3. J Carlisle (Ess)
2. N Fyfe (Fre)
1. M Hibberd (Ess)
5. Jake Carlisle
4. Michael Hibberd
3. Patrick Ryder
2. Michael Hurley
1. Brent Stanton
Round 4
St Kilda 13.13 (91) Essendon 19.14 (128) at ES
3. J Watson (Ess)
2. T Bellchambers (Ess)
1. B Stanton (Ess)
5. Jobe Watson
4. Michael Hurley
3. Scott Gumbleton
2. Brent Stanton
1. Michael Hibberd
Round 5
Essendon 18.13 (121) Collingwood 10.15 (75) at MCG
3. D Zaharakis (Ess)
2. J Watson (Ess)
1. S Sidebottom (Col)
5. David Zaharakis
4. Jobe Watson
3. Jason Winderlich
2. Michael Hibberd
1. Jake Carlisle
Round 6
Essendon 17.18 (120) GWS 12.9 (81) at ES
3. M Hibberd (Ess)
2. J Cameron (GWS)
1. S Crameri (Ess)
5. Michael Hibberd
4. Courtenay Dempsey
3. Alwyn Davey
2. Cale Hooker
1. Brendon Goddard
Round 7
Geelong 17.11 (113) Essendon 11.19 (85) at ES
3. S Johnson (Geel)
2. C Enright (Geel)
1. D Zaharakis (Ess)
5. Heath Hocking
4. Jobe Watson
3. David Zaharakis
2. Jake Carlisle
1. Michael Hibberd
Round 8
Essendon 12.14 (86) Brisbane 14.12 (96) at ES
3. D Heppell (Ess)
2. B Goddard (Ess)
1. D Zorko (Bris)
5. Brendon Goddard
4. Jake Carlisle
3. Cale Hooker
2. Michael Hibberd
1. Dyson Heppell
Round 9
Richmond 9.8 (62) Essendon 13.13 (91) at MCG
3. J Watson (Ess)
2. M Hibberd (Ess)
1. B Goddard (Ess)
5. Jobe Watson
4. Michael Hibberd
3. Courtenay Dempsey
2. Brent Stanton
1. Brendon Goddard
Round 10
Sydney 17.13 (115) Essendon 10.11 (71) at SCG
3. J Kennedy (Syd)
2. J McVeigh (Syd)
1. A Goodes (Syd)
5. Michael Hibberd
4. Brent Stanton
3. Heath Hocking
2. Jake Carlisle
1. Dustin Fletcher
Round 11
Essendon 11.11 (77) Carlton 10.12 (72) at MCG
3. J Waite (Ca)
2. J Carlisle (Ess)
1. A Walker (Ca)
5. Dyson Heppell
4. Jake Carlisle
3. Jake Melksham
2. Mark Baguley
1. Michael Hurley
Round 12
Essendon 17.13 (115) Gold Coast 11.6 (72) at ES
3. B Goddard (Ess)
2. G Ablett (GC)
1. P Ryder (Ess)
5. Brendon Goddard
4. Patrick Ryder
3. Michael Hibberd
2. Jobe Watson
1. Stewart Crameri
Round 14
West Coast 13.13 (91) Essendon 15.8 (98) at PS
3. J Watson (Ess)
2. M Priddis (WC)
1. J Carlisle (Ess
5. Jobe Watson
4. Patrick Ryder
3. Jake Carlisle
2. Jake Melksham
1. Brent Stanton
Round 15
Essendon 18.10 (118) Port Adelaide 12.16 (88) at ES
3. T Bellchambers (Ess)
2. C Hooker (Ess)
1. Brad Ebert (PA)
5. Cale Hooker
4. Tom Bellchambers
3. Brent Stanton
2. David Zaharakis
1. Dyson Heppell
Round 16
Western Bulldogs 14.6 (90) Essendon 18.13 (121) at ES
3. T Liberatore (WB)
2. J Winderlich (Ess)
1. D Heppell (Ess)
5. Jason Winderlich
4. Dyson Heppell
3. Courtenay Dempsey
2. Travis Colyer
1. Jake Carlisle
Round 17
GWS 11.11 (77) Essendon 18.8 (116) at SK
3. D Heppell (Ess)
2. M Hibberd (Ess)
1. D Shiel (GWS)
5. Travis Colye
4. Jake Melksham
3. Cory Dell'Olio
2. Dyson Heppell
1. Michael Hibberd
Round 18
Essendon 13.9 (87) Hawthorn 22.11 (143) at ES
3. L Franklin (Haw)
2. S Mitchell (Haw)
1. L Hodge (Haw)
5. Dyson Heppell
4. Jake Melksham
3. Michael Hibberd
2. David Myers
1. Nick Kommer
Round 19
Collingwood 20.13 (133) Essendon 7.12 (54) at MCG
3. L Ball (Co)
2. S Sidebottom (Co)
1. B Reid (Co
5. Jobe Watson
4. Jake Melksham
3. Dyson Heppell
2. Mark Baguley
1. Michael Hibberd
Round 20
Essendon 9.13 (67) West Coast 18.12 (120) at ES
3. B Goddard (Ess)
2. M Priddis (WC)
1. M LeCras (WC)
5. Michael Hibberd
4. Brendon Goddard
3. Jobe Watson
2. Dyson Heppell
1. Cale Hooker
Round 21
Essendon 9.16 (70) North Melbourne 17.13 (115) at ES
3. D Petrie (NM)
2. L Greenwood (NM)
1. D Wells (NM)
5. Jake Melksham
4. Michael Hibberd
3. Jobe Watson
2. Brendon Goddard
1. Mark Baguley
Round 22
Carlton 9.22 (76) Essendon 12.10 (82) at MCG
3. K Simpson (Ca)
2. J Watson (Ess)
1. M Hurley (Ess)
5. Brendon Goddard
4. Jobe Watson
3. Michael Hurley
2. Heath Hocking
1. Cale Hooker
Round 23
Essendon 9.11 (65) Richmond 15.14 (104) at MCG
3. D Jackson (Rich)
2. B Ellis (Rich)
1. A Edwards (Rich)
5. Jake Melksham
4. Michael Hibberd
3. Mark Baguley
2. Brendon Goddard
1. Nathan Lovett-Murray
Full Essendon voting
Brownlow
Jobe Watson 17
Dyson Heppell 10
Brendon Goddard 9
Michael Hibberd 8
Jake Carlisle 6
Tom Bellchambers 5
David Zaharakis 4
Ben Howlett 3
Cale Hooker 2
Brent Stanton 2
Jason Winderlich 2
Stewart Crameri 1
Michael Hurley 1
Heath Hocking 1
Patrick Ryder 1
Nobby Clarke
Jobe Watson 50
Michael Hibberd 45
Dyson Heppell 27
Jake Melksham 27
Brendon Goddard 25
Jake Carlisle 23
Brent Stanton 13
Patrick Ryder 13
Heath Hocking 13
Courtenay Dempsey 12
Cale Hooker 12
David Zaharakis 10
Michael Hurley 10
Jason Winderlich 8
Mark Baguley 8
Tom Bellchambers 7
Travis Colyer 7
Ben Howlett 4
Scott Gumbleton 3
Alwyn Davey 3
Cory Dell'Olio 3
Stewart Crameri 2
David Myers 2
Dustin Fletcher 1
Nick Kommer 1
Nathan Lovett-Murray 1