Why does it matter?
The Swans didn’t rate Mitchell, he wasn’t even playing regular/consistent senior footy for them. He’d literally done nothing when he was traded. Of course he was going to be traded for less than a bloke who has been All Australian at the time of the trade.
Shiel is going be a great addition to the side, but I think I’m even happier about how well us landing him reflects on the club. We clearly have our ■■■■ together and are genuinely heading in the right direction both on and off the field. Been a while since we could honestly say that.
You don’t turn down $2 million lightly, and he effectively did it three times so he could get to us.
I would like to get this trade done as equitably as possible. We’re getting a contracted AA caliber midfielder. If the shoe was on the foot, I’m pretty sure we’d be demanding two first round picks.
We will meet somewhere in between, and probably more on our side because yes whilst he is contracted if they don’t trade him out they are probably going to have to move on other players they prefer to keep. It’s salary cap pressure driving this decision after all.
That said we have a good trading relationship with GWS and we did exceedingly well from last years trade with them so doubt Disco will be looking to bend them over.
Since they only want picks you can probably assume they are still tight or want to salary cap bank a decent amount for next year to ensure they fight off the big offers on Kelly / Coniglio