Rank worst umpiring games vs Bombers throughout history

Let’s start with:

Anzac Day 2019

Brisbane Game 2020

Collingwood non-Anzac game 2018

GWS game 2020

Prelim Final 1996

Port Adelaide Final 2002

Richmond Round 3 1981

4 Likes

Anzac 2019 was disgraceful. That’s a good list.

And:

Sydney 2019 - Rampe post climb
Sydney 2018? - Gleeson suplex’d just after Bellchambers clear push in back

Not sure we’ve ever had a game in Sydney where umpiring rub of green been with us

5 Likes

Port 2008 where Nicholls was booed for 10 mins straight?

10 Likes

Vote carefully! Don’t forget the maggots are playing for this prestigious trophy.

14 Likes

St Kilda 2004 James Hird / Scott McClaren

13 Likes

The win vs West Coast in 2018 was something else we just forget because we won.

They had more free kicks than score at 3 qtr time

14 Likes

Yeah. And their first goal was touched on the line as well and they refused to review it.

Sydney round 2 2011

Troy Pannell at his finest

5 Likes

Round 2, 2011 vs Sydney. The Swans received 30 frees to our 8 after quarter time. Legitimately the worst umpired game I’ve ever seen

2 Likes

Anzac 2019
Brisbane 2020

The McGrath holding the ball - was it Brisbane? Or Bulldogs?

1 Like

I loved the following week wow just wow

Gold Coast last year was one of the most biased efforts I’ve ever seen. Also had this gem.

12 Likes

Anzac Day 2019.

1 Like

Brisbane.

Anzac Day 2019

I’ve sought counselling for Anzac day 2019.

5 Likes

Oh boy this thread has some potential.

Some off the top of my head:

v North 2011
v Geel 2012
v Sydney 2014
v Carlton 2017 (First meeting)

7 Likes

Just pick any of our recent games v Collingwood

2004 v St Kilda, the Scott McLaren game, the feeling in the stands that night was intense, was not at all shocked by Hird’s comments

2015 v North flies under the radar a bit in these discussions

Rnd 13 2011, we played North on a saturday arvo at Docklands.
I remember we got totally torched by the umps.

2 Likes