Re: Indigenous Support at EFC

[Houli_Dooli]

@Ants

We also bid on Coleman. Did we bid on Rioli? And tried to convince Stengle to select us.

Yep we bid on Rioli and a Freo NGA kid as well (Brandon Walker).

[Heppelltitis]

@Captain_Jack

@jonovdp

Didn’t these 2 players request a trade to us, but we refused to offer true value at the trade table?

Not quite. Hill was keen but GWS had Toby Green suspended for the first month or so of the year and refused to let him go. Rosas l don’t know about.

Incorrect. The price was a 2nd round pick for Hill. And Dodoro refused to get/give up a 2nd round pick for him. A 2nd round ■■■■■■■ pick.

[Houli_Dooli]

The price was Lewis Hayes.

[riska]

We could have taken stengle in the mid season draft, but we chose not to .

[Houli_Dooli]

He went SSP, and only with Eddie Betts on board.

We really needed someone like Eddie betts on board when we had the Daveys, Munkara, Walla, Courtney Ugle at the club.

When we got Travis Varcoe thought we might make a play for Ugle-hagan as he was his mentor a the Bulldogs.

Maybe Board warned scott off it.

[Toast]

@Heppelltitis

@Captain_Jack

Not quite. Hill was keen but GWS had Toby Green suspended for the first month or so of the year and refused to let him go. Rosas l don’t know about.

Incorrect. The price was a 2nd round pick for Hill. And Dodoro refused to get/give up a 2nd round pick for him. A 2nd round ■■■■■■■ pick.

We did offer them a future second, we didn’t have a present second at the time. GWS are the ones that said no

McCartney at the time

Despite this, Giants list boss Jason McCartney said Hill’s latest trade bid came with little forewarning and was not going to be seriously considered unless another player in a similar role was to come through, such as Hawthorn veteran Luke Breust

[Aceman]

McCartney wouldn’t have dealt with Dodo even if a first was offered

[Heppelltitis]

@Toast

@Heppelltitis

@Captain_Jack

Not quite. Hill was keen but GWS had Toby Green suspended for the first month or so of the year and refused to let him go. Rosas l don’t know about.

Incorrect. The price was a 2nd round pick for Hill. And Dodoro refused to get/give up a 2nd round pick for him. A 2nd round ■■■■■■■ pick.

We did offer them a future second, we didn’t have a present second at the time. GWS are the ones that said no

McCartney at the time

Despite this, Giants list boss Jason McCartney said Hill’s latest trade bid came with little forewarning and was not going to be seriously considered unless another player in a similar role was to come through, such as Hawthorn veteran Luke Breust

Sorry, my mistake. The price was a 2nd and a 3rd. Which still would have been a great deal for a player we desperately need.

Inside story: Bobby Hill's "relief" Bombers trade failed

[Go_Team_2.0]

He wouldn’t have won a norm smith for us that’s for sure. Who did we take with the 2nd and 3rd we needed to offer?

[Ants]

@riska

We could have taken stengle in the mid season draft, but we chose not to .

Every single club considered him too much of a risk at that point. How many months had it been since Adelaide and he parted ways mid year?

@Houli_Dooli

He went SSP, and only with Eddie Betts on board.

We really needed someone like Eddie betts on board when we had the Daveys, Munkara, Walla, Courtney Ugle at the club.

When we got Travis Varcoe thought we emphasized textmight make a play for Ugle-hagan as he was his mentor a the Bulldogs.

Maybe Board warned scott off it.

I’m pretty sure he was a delisted free agent.

[Ants]

@Aceman

McCartney wouldn’t have dealt with Dodo even if a first was offered

Then why did he trade with EFC in 2020?

[Aceman]

My understanding of it was the Caldwell trade was the straw that broke the camels back

[westozziebomber]

IN - Sibisado, Collard, Jetta

[dingus]

@brady

Why don’t you ■■■■ off?

[Kingbomber11]

Someone correct me if I’m wrong, but think I saw a preseason training photo with Travis Varcoe, dunno if he’s still involved at the club in that capacity.

Great post

[benfti]

You forgot Gibson Turner