Review Thread vs Eagles 2023 - How the west was won (by 50 points)

We weren’t ever losing that game.
BZT needs to work out a way to play on guys like Allen. I’m fine with him getting the job all night and using it as a learning opportunity.

2 Likes

ABC coronation broadcasters have a beer that needs holding…

1 Like

They had no forward pressure, but they did have Oscar Allen. Soon we will get 2MP back. Remember him?
Anyway they had 4 tackles inside 50, we had 12. Generally tackles were about equal.

1 Like

fkg lol what a weak justification.

‘youre supporting isn’t like mine so ■■■■ off’

I wish we could get running stats for the whole list, seems like the only ones that we get are the top 5 from each category, anyway wouldn’t mind seeing how he’s been going coverage wise

Hurn and Yeo both turned back the clock. Barrass was solid.
Ginbey looks like a decent pickup.

but as others said Eagles had too many wafl players playing. and our class showed in the end.

1 Like

I thought he was pretty hit and miss tbh.
He’ll come good but I find him not so damaging.

1 Like

Exhausting grind of a 50 point win which should have he been a bit more.

How many times did we kick long to tippa in the first half. He’s finishing is clearly suffering for lack of fitness. Just doesn’t have the Last burst of power he needs and it’s impacting his confidence around goal.

Martin should have been thrown on ball in that game because he was red hot and Merrett was carrying a huge load in there. Desperately need at least Shiel back.

I really think we need another marking option up forward because when we get put under pressure in our defensive half we fall down really badly at half forward.

Think it would help get Langford or stringer a better match up too.

Thought we had two guys go the ball carrier a lot tonight rather than having one close down the handball option. We clearly weren’t quite at our best.

Zerk needs to get more assertive with his positioning against fast players. Ridley was great for all bar one contest.

Back that up next week with a similar result and throw all the chips in vs Carlton to secure that win. Hopefully get a few back after the bye.

11 Likes

Looks like you are in the same boat as him. FFS get a life.

3 Likes

It’s pretty much equal, for mine.

Essendon Bombers (10 Players)
Player Injury Returning


Darcy Parish Leg/Calf 4 weeks
Dylan Shiel Leg/Calf Test
Elijah Tsatas Knee 1-2 weeks
Harrison Jones Back Season
Jake Kelly Head TBC
James Stewart Foot 6-7 weeks
Jayden Davey Knee Season
Peter Wright Shoulder 3-5 weeks
Will Setterfield Foot 5 weeks
Zach Reid Hamstring 4 weeks

West Coast Eagles (11 Players)
Player Injury Returning


Isiah Winder Knee 7-9 weeks
Jack Darling Hand 3-4 weeks
Jai Culley Knee Season
Jamaine Jones Ankle TBC
Jamie Cripps Ankle 9-10 weeks
Jeremy McGovern Hamstring 4-5 weeks
Liam Ryan Hamstring 7-9 weeks
Luke Shuey Hamstring 2-3 weeks
Nicholas Naitanui Leg/Calf 6-7 weeks
Sam Petrevski-Seton Quad 2-3 weeks
Tom Cole Ankle 6-7 weeks

They’ve got some bigger names out probably, but those big names are largely old, living on past glories, and on the way down anyway. Shuey, Naitanui and SPS are all from the Hurley draft ffs, and Darling is from Heppell’s draft. McGovern is just as old. If you’re reliant on them to be any good, you’re stuffed already.

3 Likes

WEE WOO WEE WOO WEE WOO WEE WOO

we got the EFC Fan police.

1 Like

I thought he did ok at times and adjusted himself a bit after the 3 goals were kicked. He wasn’t allowing him to take marks directly in front and was pushing him out to the flanks. He adjusted. It was a good experience for him imo.

1 Like

Maybe it’s the whisky talking but I’m lid off with Tippa. He’s slowly getting his mojo back…

2 Likes

Very one sided, basically barracking for WCE. Pav, Pav and more Pav, Pav ad nauseum. I turned the commentary off.

1 Like

BIG CHUNGUS

11 Likes

The 14 year old has spoken. Go to bed.

2 Likes

Yeah I’m with you. Terrible game but that’s all down to West Coast not is.

This wasn’t a game where we played poorly, people just forget how bad it is watching a team do full court flooding. West Coast had no chance of winning at any stage tonight. Was just all out flood to limit the damage with the odd fast break rebound.

4 Likes

u good doe?

image

Oh no, what an outrageous comment I made to be considered a melt. /s

We were just lucky we weren’t playing a decent AFL standard team. It was a standard Essendon doing no more than they needed to type of performance against poor opposition. The same type of performance that saw us lose last year.

More than 500 photos at: