Its a bit of a problem, if you recommend a player without seeing the other and evaluating him, you might miss nuances. In his final year, Mc Grath came under notice because of his dash out of the back pocket. So thats where he ended up at AFL level and he is doing a serviceable job defending against some of the best small forwards and recently back to displaying some of that dash.
I should add, McCluggage is not a big body mid. He has not been anywhere near contending for a brownlow in 8 seasons.