Nice work.
Thanks for the correction.
If the recording is what it is alleged to be, the girls could,be in for a world of hurt.
If it is what you say it is - the police wonât file charges and will issue a press release that the investigation is closed as the evidence is not sufficient to secure a conviction. I think it will end there - the players or club would be crazy to go on the counterattack and pursue the girls.
But surely that becomes a matter for the police to decide not the club.
Surely A deliberately wrongful complaint for the purpose of financial gain, would be a criminal not civil matter.
If the recording is supportive of the players, the police are kind of duty bound arenât they to pursue the matter, unless of course they claim the evidence isnât good enough.
Mind you ⌠I think many would like this to fade to grey.
Even if the girls were guilty of something ⌠no one is interested in them âŚ. Itâs those bad bad swansâ players.
Youâre kind of setting up an argument you canât lose.
Iâve got no idea what Iâm saying either.
You must be feeling quite phrasmotic.
Exactly what will happen, meanwhile, does anyone consider what the players and theyâre families have been put through.
Another prime example of Guilty by allegation it seems.
Are you suggesting what they have been through hasnât got anything to do with their actions?
What they have been through, as far as I can tell, is a club imposed sanction for breaking rules and an investigation into worse.
What part of that is on anyone else?
Paid silly money to play sport, worshipped as gods, should we pay some strippers and get weird in a hotel room with some blow and maybe get aroused together? Think of our families
I am, you caused a serious amount of pericombobulation.
Thereâs a massive nuance to this that people are completely missing.
Look at it this way: if the players got hammered, went back to their room, did blow off some strippers, and hooked up within agreed-upon boundaries, that obviously creates huge personal and family issues for them. But literally none of that matters publicly unless someone actually files a complaint. Otherwise, it never sees the light of day, nobody talks about it, and nobody ever knows it happened.
Because of that, you canât say the playersâ actions were the sole cause of this entire fallout. The real catalyst was the complaint itself, and thatâs my biggest issue with how this is being framed.
If it was a bona fide complaint made in good faith, then fine. Game on, let the chips fall where they may. But whatâs been completely sketchy from the very beginning is the exact timeline. When exactly was the call made that brought the cops out, and at what precise moment did these girls realize their clients were famous footy players and see a massive payday?
Logically, the call to the police had to happen way before anyone recorded those later conversations laying out their Machiavellian scheme. The cops are going to have to do some serious digging to get a clear picture of who did what, when, and why. Everything hinges on that initial report: was it a genuine call for help, or was it just an opportunistic windfall that fell into their laps?
The nuance is the investigation? Iâm not sure that was missed in all this to be honest
Tell me what their actions were?
Yes, making a false report to police is an offence, as is blackmail.
Really depends on whats on the recording compared with what was reported to policeâŚ.
I really donât need to tell you.
Are you implying the whole thing is false?
Iâm not implying anything because same as you, I donât have the facts.
Donât you find it odd how some people get all hysterical and righteous about an âallegedâ incident when they donât have the facts?
Facts:
They were suspended by their club for breaking team rules.
There is an investigation underway.
They are the two things Iâve covered.
Fair enough, tell me the factual evidence about the investigation youâve covered?
Iâm going to suggest I havenât made any references to evidence in an investigation because Iâm not an idiot.
I have called out those who have suggested the players and families had been wronged by there being an investigation though
Seems like you are across as much information that is avaliable, What do think is going to happen from here?
Surprise twist in legal move by dancers against Swans players caught in hotel saga
November 2, 2026 â 3:00pm
Swans player Riley Bice and retired teammate Taylor Adams remain in the frame for civil action from two exotic dancers involved in the Pullman East Melbourne hotel incident, despite being cleared by police.
Lawyers acting for the women have sent legal letters, along with a draft statement of claim, to five men and the Sydney Swans football club as a forerunner to potential action in the Supreme Court of Victoria.
Sydney player Isaac Heeney leaving the Swansâ headquarters in September .Janie Barrett
A legal source connected to the process, but not authorised to speak publicly about the matter, told this masthead the correspondence outlining the pairâs claims was addressed to Isaac Heeney, Chad Warner, North Melbourne recruit Nick Blakey, Bice and Adams.
But in a further twist, tagger James Jordon has escaped scrutiny as part of the womenâs private lawsuit while he remains subject to the ongoing police inquiry.
The source said the letter, prepared by barristers briefed by Carbone Lawyers, was also sent separately to the club with claims that, as the playersâ employer, they are therefore liable for their actions at the hotel.
They said the documentation included an invitation for the parties to begin discussions towards an agreed outcome. Letters of demand can also include a warning that court proceedings may be initiated if a matter is not resolved.
Victoria Police investigation into the pre-dawn events of August 17 at the East Melbourne hotel are ongoing, with a decision expected this month.
A spokesperson said there was âno update to provide at this stageâ when contacted for comment.
Police have already indicated Bice and Adams are being treated as witnesses.
Carbone Lawyers is representing two of the women, one based in Melbourne and the other who divides her time between Melbourne and Byron Bay.
This masthead has previously reported that the women have been medically assessed and found to be suffering trauma-related disorders following events at the hotel.
The official medical reports, one of which extended to more than 40 pages, were prepared for the potential civil action and concluded the pair were variously struggling with post-traumatic stress disorder and adjustment disorder for which they are now undergoing treatment.
A third woman in the hotel suite at the Pullman is being represented by Slater and Gordon.
The exotic dancers were engaged by the Swans players to perform in one of the playerâs hotel rooms after the teamâs round 23 win against Essendon.
The Pullman hotel in East Melbourne where the Swans were staying during their trip to Melbourne for round 23.Simon Schluter
In separate statements to Victoria Police, each of the three women variously alleged they were sexually assaulted and touched inappropriately without consent.
The players have maintained their innocence and denied any criminal wrongdoing.
After the incident, the Sydney Swans banned all five players from the field for the remainder of the 2026 season for drinking, staying out late and inviting women back to the team hotel â a breach of the clubâs behaviour standards.
Heeney won the Swansâ best and fairest last month, saying in a pre-recorded message it was the first time heâd felt positive about the future âin a long timeâ.

0:50
Heeneyâs message after winning Swans medal
Isaac Heeney sent a video message to his club after winning another Swans medal.
âWhile I wasnât able to attend the awards, I look forward to seeing you all again in person very soon.
âFrom the depths of my heart, Iâm truly sorry for putting you through the extreme difficulty youâve had to endure, as it had a huge impact on the club,â he told teammates, club officials and staff at the event.
âEvery single day I was away from the club was heartbreaking, knowing that I couldnât make a contribution. Every single day, I think about what could have been ⌠Iâm incredibly excited about what this group can do. I canât wait to get back and train with the boys, get better and attack next year together.â
Blakey was on October 12 traded to North Melbourne in an eight-year deal worth more than $11 million, after reportedly being unhappy with the way the Andrew Pridham-chaired club handled the incident.
Carbone Lawyers and the Sydney Swans both declined to comment.