The Cricket Thread (part 9) - from Dec 2024

Lunch Aus. 4/191. Curious that Bumrah wasn’t brought back, but will be on straight after the lunch break.

1 Like

This is one where it can all be righted (and thus should be) by reinstating India’s review.

Agreed but the replays the TV um saw looked different to the one the broadcaster showed a bit later.

But India lose a review because the clowns can’t follow protocol

my heart bleeds for them

1 Like

It was, but even on the Umpire footage the ball moves towards the off side then back to the onside off the edge. It went pad / bat / pad in that order.

That said, Marsh was a long way forward and I thought there was a distance at which DRS is deemed unable to track? ( And I think ball tracking is often garbage anyway).

2 Likes

Third ump has been pretty bush league all series with the reviews. The zoomed in front on HD kayo showed afterwards clearly showed pad first. Ump didn’t even check that angle and said ‘fck it’.

Yes impact would’ve been umpires call, but still. Do it properly FFS.

Also, Smiff pls retire. Pls.

3 Likes

3m rule for umps

Yeah exactly. Get the process right.

The way they rushed through the KL Rahul dismissal last test was horrible too. I still think the spike was bat hitting pad for that one but even if you think otherwise, he didn’t give it anywhere near enough consideration.

1 Like

Still amazed that the angle that showed the ball hitting pad, then deflecting to bat/pad was not available to the umpire. But as others have said, hitting in line was umpires call, so the DRS would have not overturned the on field decision.

It was only a matter of time, Marsh looked like a walking wicket.

Geez Mitch, looked all at sea against Ashwin

1 Like

Marsh gawn for 9, caught Pant off Ashwin. Marsh walked. Aus 5/208.

Still possible to get 350 from here.

Marsh walked but the comms don’t think it was out.

What do youse say about that?
And why do they take such a long time to show schnicko?

Beau Webster says hi ……should have played

1 Like

For once they’re right.

They’re a ■■■■■■■ joke!

Replay shows he didn’t hit it. But Marsh walked thinking he hit it because he hit his pad.