I need something to fill the void. been a few of these kinds of things getting around. I’ll try and put bias/hate aside. who are your top 10?
Buddy Franklin
Nat Fyfe
Luke Hodge
GAJ
Scott Pendlebury
Dustin Martin
Patrick Dangerfield
Alex Rance
Sam Mitchell
Joel Selwood
1 Like
I really wanted to make the case for Corey enright. he is one of the most underrated players the game has seen
2 Likes
All Bias aside
J Watson
D Heppell
C Hooker
M Hurley
J Daniher
D Smith
D Shiel
A Saad
J Stringer
AMT
Honerable mentions, Fyfe, Franklin, Ablett, Hodge, Pendles, Martin, Rance, Mitchell, Selwood, Judd, Danger
11 Likes
SMJ
April 1, 2020, 1:37am
4
I love this, and everyone is going to bite your head off for at least five of the names in that list! Love it
1 Like
what does Merrett have to do to get a gig?
Let’s be honest, I didn’t put much thought into it.
8-10 Will have pretty much differing opinions. the rest of them select themselves (imo)
I want to do this list just to put Sam Mitchell no 1.
1 Like
I think Pendlebury goes close to number 1, FWIW.
Buddy a few rungs down, based on the criteria given - he’s been just ‘very good‘ since about 2017 and missed a fair bit.
1 Like
I have no idea about the timeframe here.
But regardless, seems to me, clearly…
Jr
Franklin
Dusty
Raffle the rest.
just out of interest - To others as well
is fyfe underrated in Melbourne? I have no doubt if he played for a big Melbourne club, he would be top 2 with everyone, and ahead of dusty. criminally underrated, still
1 Like
He’s best footy has been in a bad team that hasn’t played finals. Those type of players generally get marked down through no fault of their own.
I probably only watch Freo once a year against us.
1 Lindsay Thomas
2 Walters
3 Stratton
4 Ryder
5 Carlisle
6 fk Carlton
7 worsfold
8 skipworth
9 Jeff Kennett
10 west coast supporters
2 Likes
the years before that, were more game changing than anyone else imo
earlier in the decade they were right up there, including a GF
he is a better player than dusty, imo
FWIW - if you want to pay attention to it, and you may not - Pendles/Martin/Fyfe/GAJ are all on 173-175 BL votes over the decade.
Danger’s on 209.
As well as being the leader of that group for clearances (by a lot), contested possession, inside 50s (by a lot) and goals (by a lot).
Perhaps we under-rate Danger.
2 Likes
Missed a bit of footy, and played under duress a bit too much.
His best is right up there.