That’s correct. We can get Shiel for 9 and a second rounder. Next years second for Scully. Otherwise forget Scully. Dodoro wont trade next years first. Especially for Scully. He’s on the record a few times saying how important is it to keep your future first round pick because you have no idea what needs you’ll have the following year.
1 Like
Hawthorn won two premierships without Franklin. Have also won 10 in the last 40 years. They have been doing something right over the journey.
1 Like
Fair enough.
1 Like
Scully and his foot???
How many cafes could there possibly be in a country town ?
Do another round, but I advise sticking to de-cafs for the remainder of the day !
1 Like
690 new posts.
Did we get Martin?
Please don’t tell me we landed Scully!!
GWS not demanding as much as you thought, hey, Uncle Chop? 
1 Like
Ok.
It’s great listening to Stephen Silvagni talk about how disappointed his is with the Shiel situation.
17 Likes
Music to our ears
Your club is ■■■■. Why would good players go there!
We’ve had over the past 3 years the following select us when Blues thought they had them
2016 - Stewart
2017 - Smith & Saad
2018 - Shiel
Yes they got Setterfield but Shiel would have been our priority anyway.
May it continue
3 Likes
Somebody said on here the other day we should trade our fourth rounder for Jack Silvagni and then delist him.
SAVAGE
10 Likes
When you farking serve up caviar to a prospective trade target,would he not think the whole thing smelt fishy?
9 Likes
300 new posts. Is Shiel signed on now, or is it scully, is it martin or is it more coffee talk?
I’m glad the Lobster Cave thing was bullshit. Otherwise we might be in the same situation.
1 Like
It’s that feeling you get when people you don’t know are too nice and or familiar…
1 Like
I just have no interest in Scully.
With his age bracket, and coming off an injury, it just doesn’t fit our strategy.
If virtually free however, then I’d be happy to take him off of GWS hands for the salary cap dump. Other then that, I’m not really sure why we are interested.
8 Likes
Yeah but as SOS put it, when you add those points together they’ve essentially given them pick 15… fixed
10/22 games against those 5 sides? It would be maximum 8. But I get your point
He’s best 22 and would make our team better. Midfield is probably the area we are weakest, he runs hard both ways. I’d happily take him.
3 Likes
Me too. I think this is why his value on the market seems to be 3rd round. Clubs aren’t killing each other to get him.