Trade talk - from August 2024

if only we had the Romanised version of max on the list still

Durham

Or Duursma. X is basically living in D50 as it is pushing deep into D from wing anyways…

I agree…reakon we should play Durham off half back. Has pace, great in the contest, good mark and good distributer.

Yup.

In fact, if you go back to all the comments pre-season, the loudest voices expected us to finish bottom 4.

Foot injuries and spine fractures are our specialty

2 Likes

We desperately need better users of the ball. Im really, really unsure if he’s the right fit but i can see us looking at liam ryan off half back if he decides to move because he’sa good kick. But, i question his motivation and he’s injury prone, so probably not

Caleb daniel would be another option for kicking skills

Or, we could have just kept massimo. FMD

9 Likes

Houston would help as a neat distributor off HB

2 Likes

Nuh that would be another Martin move. Moving one of our best players out of the midfield, robbing Peter to pay Paul.

Half back is the easiest position on the field, could get any busted forward flanker or mid with good foot skills to move back there and do a good job. El hawli can even play there if needed.

1 Like

This is where I had him in my best 22. Don’t think there’s room in the forward line for him.

1 Like

Young blokes will huff about this…. But I always go back to Sheedy’s philosophy.

If you aren’t an elite ball user, you better be a tough MF.

We waste so much draft capital on in between players. It’s time to draft elite ball users or tough ā– ā– ā– ā– ā– . Nothing in between.

31 Likes

Quite extraordinary we have largely avoided drafting either

11 Likes

Tsartas to HBF to improve the collective kicking skills of our backline!

6 Likes

Whys is there so much hate with stringer by the way and everyone wants him out?
Players like stengle in talks for AA but stringer has kicked the same amount of goals and more goal assists? He may be 30 but coming of equal second best year in his career from goals. Missed some big shots at the end of the year but at least he gives himself the opportunity and you would normally back him. I think our issue if playing him deep when he should play half forward.

3 Likes

I’m not against this at all to be honest.

That’s damning.

2025 lineup:

B. Kelly - McKay - Reid
HB. Redman - Ridley - Martin - Merrett - Durham - Caldwell - A Davey - J Davey - Houston - Cumming - Rosas

2 Likes

14 in defence and we would still concede red time coast to coast goals :rofl:

14 Likes

It’s the inconsistency, fluctuating effort and periods of looking unfit. I think it looks impressive when you look at the season goals for Jake, and that’s all he looks at whilst preparing for his exit interview no doubt - but it is the way he goes missing and looks unfit for patches of the season. Realistically, Jake should be one of the top 20 players in the league, which he is for a handful of games each year, yet overall he is nowhere near that.

2 Likes

Can we please for one game have the backline of

Cumming Cox McKay

1 Like

We look for accumulators and good families.

5 Likes