This should stoke the fire as to who is “better”. Rance (28 yoa) competed in more 1:1 contests , each won 80%. Hurls zoned off more and was more attacking. Unfortunately, Hurls ( 27yoa) tailed off towards the end of the season, but also started it a bit out of touch after being out of the game for a year.
Clearly, if Rance was AA Hurls would have to be also. Stoppers like Talia & Ambrose are OK at what they do, but are much more limited players.
R50s 3.88 I50s 0.88 per game
R50s 6.9 I50s 1.19 per game
Conclusion, Rance and Hurley are very close and if Rance is the GOAT, its not by much.