Those injuries are horrible and we will struggle terribly without any ruckman.
Hardy into the ruck!
In your opinion jackie, will fletcher and chappy play?
I don't have any special knowledge that would enable me to say.
Everyone please note that I said I SUSPECT Carlislle won't play as far as I would venture to GUESS. I'm being guarded in my comments and don't put it forward as a fait accompli but neither is it a comment made without any foundation. I call it as I see it but like all of you I will have to wait until Sunday to know.
Based on Jobe's advice, will KAV! play?
In your opinion jackie, will fletcher and chappy play?
I don't have any special knowledge that would enable me to say.
Everyone please note that I said I SUSPECT Carlislle won't play as far as I would venture to GUESS. I'm being guarded in my comments and don't put it forward as a fait accompli but neither is it a comment made without any foundation. I call it as I see it but like all of you I will have to wait until Sunday to know.
Why so guarded with the information? I'm not sure why the secrecy.
He either trained, or he didn't. We don't need a medical diagnosis however, just an idea, instead of numerous posts with everyone trying to guess.
In your opinion jackie, will fletcher and chappy play?
I don't have any special knowledge that would enable me to say.
Everyone please note that I said I SUSPECT Carlislle won't play as far as I would venture to GUESS. I'm being guarded in my comments and don't put it forward as a fait accompli but neither is it a comment made without any foundation. I call it as I see it but like all of you I will have to wait until Sunday to know.
Why so guarded with the information? I'm not sure why the secrecy.
He either trained, or he didn't. We don't need a medical diagnosis however, just an idea, instead of numerous posts with everyone trying to guess.
Yep, cause Jackie hasn't given nearly enough to this site over the last few months.
I reckon Jackie is a Freo plant.
Carlisle is probably walking around in a moon boot for a laugh.
Maybe Belly is ready for AFL action...
welcome to 2014 no practice matches and first game against sandilands at Subi....still 3/4 from tom would be better than thurlow. would have to sub him out though.
I think this is a very unlikely scenario
Maybe Belly is ready for AFL action...
welcome to 2014 no practice matches and first game against sandilands at Subi....still 3/4 from tom would be better than thurlow. would have to sub him out though.
I think this is a very unlikely scenario
Belly and Kommer is going to Perth though. This is confirmed.
Maybe Belly is ready for AFL action...
welcome to 2014 no practice matches and first game against sandilands at Subi....still 3/4 from tom would be better than thurlow. would have to sub him out though.
I think this is a very unlikely scenario
Belly and Kommer is going to Perth though. This is confirmed.
??
??
Belly and Kommer is going to Perth though. This is confirmed.
welcome to 2014 no practice matches and first game against sandilands at Subi....still 3/4 from tom would be better than thurlow. would have to sub him out though.
Maybe Belly is ready for AFL action...
I think this is a very unlikely scenario
they are doing a function on the sat night here, and between 1-2 will be at the merchandise stand at subi doing a signing session
The supercoach page is listing Hardy as being injured too (Quad: Subject to fitness test).
So outs could be Chappy, Hardy, Carlisle, Fletcher, with no Ryder/Ambrose/Kommer to come back in.
Still...
Pears Hurley Bags
Hibberd Hooker Gleeson
Watson Zaka Hocking
JD Myers Heppel
Howlett Melksham Licha
Jerret Goddard Stanton
Ashby, Zerret, Colyer, Van Unen
Would prefer someone to take on Sandilands other than JD, so JD can at least play as a tall decoy in the FWD line.
The supercoach page is listing Hardy as being injured too (Quad: Subject to fitness test).
So outs could be Chappy, Hardy, Carlisle, Fletcher, with no Ryder/Ambrose/Kommer to come back in.
Still...
Pears Hurley Bags
Hibberd Hooker Gleeson
Watson Zaka Hocking
JD Myers Heppel
Howlett Melksham Licha
Jerret Goddard Stanton
Ashby, Zerret, Colyer, Van Unen
Would prefer someone to take on Sandilands other than JD, so JD can at least play as a tall decoy in the FWD line.
Pears is struggling with injury, did not play last weekend.
And when ever was the grand plan for Daniher to be the "tall decoy in the FWD line?"
Last i heard pears was also injuredThe supercoach page is listing Hardy as being injured too (Quad: Subject to fitness test).
So outs could be Chappy, Hardy, Carlisle, Fletcher, with no Ryder/Ambrose/Kommer to come back in.
Still...
Pears Hurley Bags
Hibberd Hooker Gleeson
Watson Zaka Hocking
JD Myers Heppel
Howlett Melksham Licha
Jerret Goddard Stanton
Ashby, Zerret, Colyer, Van Unen
Would prefer someone to take on Sandilands other than JD, so JD can at least play as a tall decoy in the FWD line.
If carlisle and paddy both miss we have to upgrade thurlow surely?
Do we have anymore tall forward options left at all?
Last i heard pears was also injuredThe supercoach page is listing Hardy as being injured too (Quad: Subject to fitness test).
So outs could be Chappy, Hardy, Carlisle, Fletcher, with no Ryder/Ambrose/Kommer to come back in.
Still...
Pears Hurley Bags
Hibberd Hooker Gleeson
Watson Zaka Hocking
JD Myers Heppel
Howlett Melksham Licha
Jerret Goddard Stanton
Ashby, Zerret, Colyer, Van Unen
Would prefer someone to take on Sandilands other than JD, so JD can at least play as a tall decoy in the FWD line.
If carlisle and paddy both miss we have to upgrade thurlow surely?
Do we have anymore tall forward options left at all?
Oops, Pears would have been ■■■■■■ handy if fletch is to miss.
Agree on the Thurlow upgrade. In hindsight we still would have belted Carlton last week with Thurlow in the side, and Carlisle might not have been hurt. Don't want one of our remaining talls getting injured against Sandy.
****
And Begbie, he's still a kid and he's only played 7 games, running around as a decoy is about all he's doing at the moment.
Hardy is fine. He had a corky, not a fkg quad. That supercoach page knows fk all
lol at everyone going nuts with selection. I bet we will have two changes, max
Just out of curiosity once a rookie has been upgraded is it possible to put him back onto rookie list and upgrade another in his place?
What is this crap re Carlisle.
Nope.Just out of curiosity once a rookie has been upgraded is it possible to put him back onto rookie list and upgrade another in his place?
What is this crap re Carlisle.
Hahaha here he is!