Votes vs Melbourne GR 2025

3 Durham
2 Draper
1 Merrett

Durham
Draper
Shiel

My voting justified. Midfielders other than Merrett and Setterfield don’t deserve votes for that game.

Surprised Draper who had 22 touches, 4 contested marks at critical points in the game, 5 clearances and 470 metres gained playing on Gawn couldn’t get a game over Nankervis who had 17 touches, 0 contested marks, 5 clearances and 21 metres gained.

1 Like

3 Merrett
2 Draper
1 Setterfield

Stats is one thing. Contested marking was good. But he is in the side to ruck and Gawn owned him on the ruck contests

If Draper had broken even in the ruck, he’d have been big for mine. His presence and especially ball use was outstanding. Some of his kicks were amazing. And his turn away from Redman (instead of giving him the obvious ball) not only broke Rivers’ (?) ankles, but more generally cleared Redman’s path.

He got killed for centre clearances but still a very good outing.

1 Like

He had 6 coaches votes to Gawn’s 2. Nankervis didn’t get a single vote. Was clearly the most influential big man on the ground against the best in the biz, think he should have been in the team of the week.

4 Likes

Yeah agree with comparison to Nank

This sounds silly but coaches votes are not a good guide. Two independent voters with their own motives.

Particularly when they don’t agree with the line you’re pushing eh?

1 Like

3 Merrett
2 Durham
1 Reid