The umpires were ok in the first half and part of the third. They rocketed to the bottom of the umpiring fraternity after the worst decisions ever seen in front of an oppositions goal X 3 to give the P&P chicks a sniff of a, unbeknownst to them, comeback. Worst I have seen since last week.
Yes and no. Unlike most modern day commentators he takes a position and backs it in. Never sits on the fence. I often disagree with him but always enjoy listening to him talk about footy.
I suppose you believe he has played everyone in position all year and had the correct ins and outs. You forgot the criticism of Woosha after a terrible loss where he played the wrong players in wet conditions. Right or wrong some losses could have been accepted had he not made some obviously sh ite decisions.