What Would be Your Mid-Season B&F?


#1

I reckon mine would be:

Heppell
Shiel
Stringer
Merrett
Parish

McGrath
Saad
McDonald-Tipungwuti
Hurley
Hooker

just misses out: Guelfi


#2

Ambrose says hi.


#3

yeahhhh true hmm


#4

Stringer
Ambrose
Hooker
Saad
Shiel

Would be my top 5. Tippa and Heppell thereabouts.


#5

Myers
Baguley
Zaka

Easiest decision of my life


#6
  1. Heppell.
  2. Shiel.
  3. Zerrett.
  4. Stringer.
  5. Ambrose.

#7

1.Stringer- our most consistent and had a few big games in there as well

2.Ambrose- having his best season ever. Reckon he has had only one poor game so far this year. Plays within his limitations and never over complicates things either

3 Shiel. Has delivered on exactly what was needed when we got him

Most improved: David Myers


#8

Saad has been our best player this year, followed closely by daylight and then a truckload more daylight. Heppell and Stringer very good.


#9

1 Stringer most consistent good player
2 Shiel
3 Heppell
4 Hooker
5 Saad
6 Hurley
7 Ambrose
8 Merrett
9 Zaharakis
10 MCDonaldTipungwuti


#10
  1. Merrett (quite comfortably)
  2. Shiel
  3. Saad
  4. Stringer
  5. Heppell

#11

Stringer
Ambrose
Heppell


#12

Seems about right.
Saad would be in the mix.
Players like T-Bell, McKenna, Tippa, Parish, Fantasia (in his six games) have been inconsistent.
Hurley and Hooker would probably be top ten through weight of games.
Oh, and McGrath will be 6-10.

So…
6. Saad
7. McGrath
8. Zaharakis
9. Hurley
10. Parish


#13

agree with all except zaka


#14

Heppell for mine, followed by Shiel, Saad, Stringer and Ambrose.


#15

Lol just shows how differently we all see the same thing.

Heppell… Saad… Ambrose… Hooker…

Redman has to be up there… Stringer has been good but missing games will hurt him… Hurls solid but his decision making and lack of composure often bite.


#16

Stringer.


#17

Heppell
Ambrose
Stringer
Shiel
Hooker


#18

Hep, stringer and McGrath. Hooker and Hurley as well would make the top 5.

Shiel started slowly but found his feet.

Others have played well in a few games but those 5 have been the most consistent.


#19

They had Tippa in the top five when he was, objectively, one of the worst if not The worst on the ground, so trying to match Essendon’s b&f is a fools errand.


#20

How is this even a discussion, who comes 2nd?.

Stringer by a country mile… And then some.