I disagree with that
5 Likes
They won’t delist anyone in 2 weeks. They’ll wait until after the trade period because they’ll think that there are other clubs interested and they might get something in a trade. It’s ridiculous
I’m personally hoping you can explain why you chanted a few weeks ago that the players were doing it for Woosha, and now all that’s just vanished.
Not true (or at least a gross simplification).
He’s currently failing in a variety of roles, not just midfield. He got dumped to the backline after failing yesterday, for example, and despite that area being peppered was still very meh.
His first midfield game (since he was a junior) was vs Sandy, 26 disposals. After that he’s bounced around in a mix of forward/mid/back and has got between 13 and 20 disposals each week – until the last three weeks of 3, absent, and 10 (with 4 of those collected very late yesterday).
He was notably an outside mid yesterday, often standing a few metres behind the stoppage. That might be fine if you have a Dylan Clarke or Myers to feed it out, but we were being thoroughly thrashed in the ruck (60-34) and everywhere else.
I suspect he’s been injured the last three weeks (right knee?) but if you’re playing it would be nice if you, like, played.
And no, I don’t see him being cut this year, as some hyperbolic types are saying.
5 Likes
He’s been playing very well, actually… absolutely in the top handful of VFL players this second half of the season.
2 Likes
I said I was wrong that I had originally said he had lost the players. I have maintained for a long time that he is a awful coach
After the crows game I said there was a tiny chance that I might of been wrong. The GC game proved that I wasn’t wrong
Have a read of the Langford thread!
Posters complaining in one post that the club doesn’t persist with youngsters, then in the next post that that the club does persist with Langford.
A few results go against, and our supporters just lose all logic and perspective and start throwing their poo at the walls.
5 Likes
Yeah I probably did oversimplify it.
1 Like
Drawing a very long bow here with pure speculation.
Our injuries have obviously caught up with us and it is not unexpected that we couldn’t keep pulling wins out of our arses these last 2 weeks, but is there any chance that a Woosha departure /Caracella succession plan has affected player morale?
Just trying to think of why our form/intent could so completely disappear other than we were hanging onto our structure by a thread which has simply snapped.
2 Likes
Can you do me a favour and read my query again.
Hopefully you can have a better crack at it, than what you just served up.
In the past eight matches, we have played about 50 minutes of good football. I don’t see much difference to how we played against West Coast, Sydney, Gold Coast, and most of the other games in the past two months.
I really don’t think our form has changed that significantly at all.
I would say there’s a very good chance of this.
1 Like
Harding’s planned exit could be another broken straw.
1 Like
Worsfold just sat there and made no moves, like a stone statue, Worsfold could have put 2 players behind the ball to stop the bleeding, he’s a completed joke as a coach and should be sack, what a joke recruiting Shied waste of 2 first-round picks. Has he made us better
No way. The form last night was a lot different to the earlier part of that winning streak.
2 Likes
No wonder it smells in here
Can you do me a favour and read my post again champ. I spelled it out, would you like it in crayon?
Or you, a player has been given ample chances to prove he is up to it, and hasn’t. Maybe that’s why he is being bagged
He’s not the only one struggling to understand your posts - it’s you, not all of us.
Something about listing 4 or 5 of us was meant to be a question, I think?
1 Like