#7 Zerrett in the beginning

[theDJR]

We’ll appeal. We always appeal.

Because that has worked for us in the past lol

Doesn’t Adrian Anderson have a 100% hit rate for us?

[chef]

Can confirm, it was televised… mentioned earlier on this site.

Thanks for that, didn’t see it at the game and haven’t been brave enough to watch the replay (except for the last 10 mins).

Do the MRP take that into consideration at all, I wonder?

They don’t, but if someone hit him hard enough to make him throw up, there should be footage of it, and whoever did it should have been suspended.

Casboult elbow to the kidneys half way through Q2

[handypoint]

Must be a show on appeal. The AFL’s own preview show of MRP gave it low impact and a fine.

[Aceman]

Casboult charged into the back of him after a mark with a elbow and gave away the 50. I had no problem with it infact it’s exactly what we should be doing

[Aceman]

Was nothing wrong with it, Casboult just gave him one to think about. I liked it even though it was on Zac

[Kruzin]

How the ■■■■■■■ ■■■■ ■■■■■■■ ■■■■ ■■■■■■■■ ■■■■ did he not get suspended for that! Fuckwitts Ng ■■■■■!!!

[SplitRound]

I didn’t see it, was just commenting on the concept.

[frosty]

the kids been belted for the last 3 years because hes by far our best player and has one outburst and we’re labelling him dumb?

fmd.

Not sure how accurate it is - but on another forum, they were saying that Zach was throwing up on the bench after some contact - not sure if anyone else can confirm that? I didn’t see it myself. But can see why he’d react if he’d been copping it like that during the game.

Going the Van der Haar defence…argue that he didn’t have all his faculties after the earlier hit.

[Blakey]

Paste that GIF of cotchin all over the AFL twitter acount… that’ll make them change their tune… optics…

[Go_Team_2.0]

What is Zach going to argue at the appeal? That he didn’t punch anyone? Take your week kid.

[Go_Team_2.0]

Paste that GIF of cotchin all over the AFL twitter acount… that’ll make them change their tune… optics…

Probably make them more convinced they got call right this time.

[Dons-All-The-Way]

What is Zach going to argue at the appeal? That he didn’t punch anyone? Take your week kid.

No but the argument is the classification of medium impact. That could be downgraded to low.

[scotty21]

If it was the medical from FC that got this to medium impact then that medical form must have been plowman’s death certificate

[frosty]

Played out rest of game = medium
Concussed and can’t return = medium

Dangerfield clearly should have been high

[Aceman]

FCFC have a reputation for exaggerating their medical reports. Poor Kreuzer was nearly declared dead after that tackle by Danger and all of a sudden just like Lazarus he plays against us and was their best player

[Diablo]

If he was chucking his guts after the hit, i dont see how you could argue against medium impact.

[Wanderlust]

If he was chucking his guts after the hit, i dont see how you could argue against medium impact.

I assumed Merrett was throwing up after being hit, not Plowman.

[andrewb]

■■■■ CARLTON

[wannabe]

Precedent has never been a factor as long as I can remember. I think it’s because they don’t have time since they often have multiple cases and only a day or so to deliver a verdict.
Zach punched a guy and if it winded him or impacted his performance in the slightest then it’s medium, could have broken a rib or could fit the guys face by “accident”, so agree need to stamp that out.

[kingofthehill]

It’s frustrating because of precedent, but it would be madness to risk another week trying to argue that wasn’t medium impact - it was.