Both Guelfi and Snelling are good pressure forwards but while both are very serviceable we do need an upgrade on both.
2 Likes
Hope Guelf pulls up ok
Stayed down after tackles and bumps quiet a few times tonight
Since this article, we have lost 5 of the last 6 games, including our worst games, If by more consistent, heās referring consistently ā ā ā ā , then he is correct!
Guelf is a limited footballer skills wise. His best attribute is his desperation and 1% efforts which as vital to a team like ours that has historically been very soft.
He plays a game style that requires him to be on the edge to be most effective, which he was last year hence the high B&F finish.
In the past this has been when his spot in the team is not assured and he has had to grind for every loose ball and chase down lost causes.
Post bye he seems to be very comfortable in the side and thus his desperation and effort has reduced.
We need him back to his desperate best, otherwise iād rather have a more highly skilled player in his spot developing.
Maybe dropping him may be the key to getting the best out of him.
2 Likes
He has lost the manic pressure he had this year. I think Menzie has shown more of that kind of pressure this year. Problem is all our small forwards are in the wrong spots. Too far up the ground when the ball is kicked in. Should hunt in pairs: 2MP and Guelfi, Langford and Menzie.
2 Likes
20 pressure acts for Guelf vs 22 for Menzie last week
Isnāt he a Perf boy? Straight swap for Oscar.
When you miss easy goals like that -hack comes to mind
3 Likes
I always liked him but has been ordinary this year. Isnāt dangerous at all, would prefer tippa.
1 Like
Terrible couple of weeks. Yeah, give someone else a go.
1 Like
Enough with this guy
1 Like
Work on your Instagram or your disposal. Make up your mind.
2 Likes
Delist . Offers nothing
2 Likes
Whatās happened to him? Heās not a patch on the player we saw last year. He has to be playing with something. He canāt be this bad.
1 Like
Yep, pay him out - same with Stewart.
Last year he played with desperation and did the unselfish team things. This year he is a show pony who isnāt. He spent half the pre game warmup trying Hollywood snaps and checksides
Drop this jobber
1 Like
People will get mad and bring up the fact he finished top 3 in our best and fairest but if we are serious as a club (which is questionable at best) weāre moving past small forwards like Guelfi
1 Like
Missed about half the year with that injury, and he seems to be playing differently to last year. I reckon he stays off the contest a lot, where heād typically go in hard. So heās a lot less involved physically. No idea whatās driving that.
3 Likes
Injury makes sense. So heās not playing to his strengths to play his role? If so, thereās no spot for him.