Not all. Definitely not all
Disagree. Think he 100% entirely lived up to his potential. Heās a good role player. He was never going to be anything more than that.
10 Likes
And had Stewart the week before
I think playing consistently, and consistently injury free, heād be rated higher. On Thursday a Carlton fan was disparaging him saying his goals were a third of his total for the season. Youāre never getting rated when you only play half the games, kick 10 or so goals and shut down a few good players. Play multiple full seasons with 15-30 goals and multiple shut down jobs and youāll be rated very differently.
1 Like
I couldnāt care less how a Fark Cartlon or any other person rates him. My comment had nothing to do with how he is rated.
1 Like
Oh I agree his ceiling was never high, just that injuries have stopped him reaching it. A good defensive forward is the definition of a āroleā player.
1 Like
Guelfi doing everything wrong so far with his 5 ineffectual disposals.
And calf injury.
Would genuinely pay out his last year after that pitiful performanceā¦.finishing in a classic Guelfi soft tissue it seems.
Iām just an internet forum nuffy but Guelf seems like one of the main āpoor standardsā operator. Loves what comes with being an AFL player.
4 Likes
The old Geulfi corked calf hey? Cant stop getting corkies in the calf. Poor bugger is well and truly cooked.
1 Like
He was almost invisible last night, l had to look twice to make sure it was him. He usy plays with some physical presence, but was a complete non factor.
Aside from a couple of them having a dip, most were invisible.
1 Like
Iam probably reading into more than it needs to be but it felt like weird timing last night that sub.
He got a stray scratch to the face and went down like he was shot then subbed for a cork and seemed to be walking around fine afterwards I didnāt see him with ice on it
4 Likes
I donāt know what was up with him, but before being injured it was one of his worst games Iāve seen. Not alone in that thoughā¦
1 Like
Heās just not that good
Disagree, I think Guelfi is a good role player. He can play the defensive fwd role well and is smart around goal. Heās one of our better tacklers / pressure players. His issue in recent years is availability, like 50% of the list.
4 Likes
Pay him out and delist
is just a jobber. Only plays a few good games a year. Injuries are starting to pile up. And I have big question marks over how much work he puts in off the field in the gym. He has been in the system for a long time, and still looks very skinny
Laters
2 Likes
Pay him out? Interesting take. I guess if weāre going complete scorched earth policy itās an option.
I like what he brings to the forward line, but ultimately it isnāt enough. For us to take steps forward, we need to move past Guelfi, and l say this as a fan of his. He canāt contribute to progress if he spends half his games sitting in the stands.
4 Likes
Yep, burn it all down and start again
1 Like