Shiel can get it, receive it and burst away from a stoppage but most want him dumped?
1 Like
Shiel will have a good season next year being his last
Elijah is a God, Brownlow winner in the next 5 years (maybe not at Essendon).
Deal with it Blitz.
If all midfielders could play at their potential we could have one of the best midfield in the comp
A Durham Caldwell Parish
B Merrett Martin Shiel
C Tsatas Perkins Hobbs
has to be deepest midfield group in a while.
compare to finals 2021 year
A Stringer Parish Merrett
B McGRath Shiel Smith
C Langford Caldwell Snelling
maybe I’m a bit like Grant Heale and overrating us…2021 Stringer was elite. will need another big jump from Duzza and Caldwell. Martin could surprise, shiel turn back the clock.
Tsatas/Hobbs emerge.
compare to swans
A Warner Heeney Gulden All genuine A grade
B Mills Adams Rowbottom
C Jordan Cleary Roberts
Most want him dumped because of his age. He’s a better player than Parish fwiw, I’d play neither of them and give bigger minutes to Tsatas even if it meant we lost more.
Shiel is absolutely not a better player than Parish LOL
11 Likes
Disagree
1 Like
Thats fine, but you are wrong.
Prime Shiel theres a fair argument.
Current Shiel is not in any way shape or form a better player than Parish.
■■■■ comparison. Comparing both in their prime Shiel has Parish covered everyday.
2 Likes
Current Parish is injured all the time, both limited footballers, at least Shiel has speed. Both aren’t what we need going forward. Parish has time on his side at least.
4 Likes
Everyone on here knows you dont like Parish mate, you dont need to reply to every comment that someone talks about him.
Prime Parish was 21, he was unbelievable that year.
Its a bloody shame he’s been injured since.
2 Likes
Agree.
1 Like
Prime Shiel is far superior to prime Parish
But I think Tsatas could be better than both
1 Like
Tbf, I’m harsh on Parish a bit as well
'Cause your Parish boner isn’t bleedingly obvious
Parish’ best year in 21, he was getting tagged week in week out and was beating teams by himself.
Shiel was also really good in his prime but has never had that influence on games. He was never the best midfielder at GWS.
Thats my two pence anyway.
5 Likes
I was genuine, I find that reply bizarre. Just out of interest who do you think has been our best inside mid since Jobe?
Merrett
Wouldn’t be surprised if Brad continues to play him in the VFL at the beginning of the season.
If he is good enough he will get a game.
1 Like