I am assuming you must have been too young to see the midfield of Tim Watson, Leon Baker, Merv Neagle, and Daisy Williams backed up by Glenn Hawker, Alan Ezard etc.
(Also the midfield of D. Reynolds and B. Hutchison had 5 Brownlows between them, so could not have been too shabby).
You are right, there. Simon was not renowned for his pace, but for the young ones, he was widely acknowledged as the best ruckman of that decade (at least).
I remember Greg Williams saying after a State of Origin game once, when he first played with Simon instead of against him, what an armchair ride he got that day.
While he roved to Harry Madden for years & got the ball tapped in his general direction, Simon just kept shoving it down his throat all day.
Also kicked almost 600 goals. Fair effort for a ruckman, I only saw him play when I was a little kid but he still sticks in my mind as the best ruckman I have seen. He is in calculations for top 3 ruckman of all time in my opinion.
Yes, he can turn it over but that’s going to happen when you are consistently trying to hit the most difficult targets in the game.
Zach Merrett (Essendon)
Ranked above average for midfielders. He rated elite for disposals, uncontested possessions and metres gained, though his kick rating was below average.
I don’t think you can even compare the midfields of say 2000 onwards with earlier midfields.
Old midfields were rover and resting forward-pocket rover, possibly ruck-rover (only really came in in Barassi’s day in the 50s), possibly ruckman (some were immobile, some were agile) and the two wingers. Half forward flankers were half forward flankers etc etc.
Difference being his clangers his kicks long. kicks more than 40m to a 50/50 contest are efficient regardless of whether you retain possession (iirc). A 50 metre kick too your full forward which is marked by the full back because it wasn’t too advantage is efficient.
Zerret goes short far more often so unless we retain it it is inefficient.