Best 22 2019 - Round 1

While Guelfi has been training with the mids I think that is more a learning experience to round out his game. I still expect him to play predominantly back when selected with maybe occasional runs through the midfield

1 Like

Yes, the forwards, backs and rucks

2 Likes

Of which the changes this year, from what I can recall of training reports are;
Longy- backs
Guelfi- mids
Laverde- mids? Unclear? Any help?
Begley??

And the experiments of last years preseason of Dlarke as a forward, Hooker forward, Brown back seem to have been dropped.

Laverde has been training with the forwards and Begley has been with the modified players so hasnā€™t been in any of the specialised groups

From what Iā€™ve seen, as Nackers said above, but Laverde has spent more time in the middle than in previous years, and Begley hasnā€™t really ventured into mid territory.

Yep.

And even if you do have a bad little spell of injuries, thatā€™s an opportunity within that to try new things which then improves your squad depth and/or flexibility.

Any recommendations on where to sit? Iā€™m going up there for the first time.

Dea :hugs:

Will Begley be right to go by then?

James Stewart or Smack who you got.

Why isnā€™t anyone asking who your 7th defender is?

I think heā€™ll be fit but I would be surprised if he doesnā€™t play some games in the reserves first to get confidence back in his body

If it makes you feel better.
Maxx
Who is your seventh defender?
Or to be clear, who provides the interchange relief for your backline?
Langford Parish Begley Myers?

Not ā– ā– ā– ā– ā– ā–  likely.

2 Likes

I posted something the other day that might answer the question:

Your maths is wrong.
Try looking at percentages of time on the ground for the 4 small / medium defenders only

Trying to add all percentages by a nominal positional basis leads you into pixie land. Thereā€™s a reason Essendon and most other sides name a defender on the interchange.

Iā€™m actually excited for this season, which canā€™t be a good thing.

Going to head to that filth shithole next Thursday

5 Likes

An updated Best 22 - my guess at who the selectors may actually pick vs GWS.
(Players named as per first bounce)

Saad Hooker Francis
Gleeson Hurley McKenna
McGrath Heppell Zaharakis
Walla Joey Langford
Stringer Fanta Zlarke

Belly Shiel Merrett
I/C Smith Parish Myers Guelfi

Not what Iā€™d originally considered but I wanted to see what the two ruckmen might mean.
GWS is short of rucks for Round 1 - it may give us a serious advantage at stoppages by playing two.

Note Fanta at FF is based on the ā€œ clear everyone else outā€ strategy teams are reportedly considering for the new centre bounces rules.

Gleeson if not match fit replaced by Redman- I think theyā€™ll take a punt here on either player.

Not just one reason. There needs to be cover in case of an injury on each line. That doesnā€™t necessarily mean covering both key defenders and small-medium defenders on the bench for example. Having a specialist tall defender on the bench would be silly, but having a swingman would be great. Brown is ideal for that, because he is mobile and can even play on the wing.
If a Saad / McKenna went down, McGrath or Baguley would move to the back end, and one of the mids eg Smith or Guelfi could cover for them. Ideally the bench would have 1 medium tall defender, one medium/tall forward and 2 mids. but The Langford can cover the tall forward role, so 1 medium (plays) tall defender and 3 mids incl Langford might do the trick.

So, "There are reasons why Essendon and most other sides name a defender on the interchange.

Oh wow, I seriously didnā€™t realise one of our JLT matches was in Melbourne, rather than out woop woop. Iā€™ll definitely go.

Makes me wonder if Iā€™ll need a ticket. Remember that preseason game in 2016 there where I think it was just about full?

On a related topic (kind of) - for Round 1, does anyone have any recommendations on where to sit in Spotless Stadium? Iā€™ve never been there and am flying up to see the Dons there for the first time. Tickets havenā€™t yet been released by the AFL, but I thought Iā€™d start seeking suggestions.

Or should I start a new thread about the Round 1 game?

1 Like

Do you think Zlarke will be in over McKernan?