We should have taken Cyril Rioli instead of David Myers.
B; Wanganeen Richards Jacobs
hb: Solomon Carlisle Hardwick
c: Caracella Blumfield Lovett
hf; Cockatoo-Collins J.Daniher Kickett
f: Fantasia Cummings Ryder
R: Salmon Heffernan Melksham
Int: Houli Crameri Moorcroft Saad
E: Barnes Hibberd Monfries Manton
Not many good inside mids have left us.
1 Like
Did he ever go to another team? Lol.
It’s a strong team, any nominations as to which clubs would be stronger?
Carlton come to mind as they have a few good players leave over that period:
Bloody strong group of forwards- Kennedy, Betts, Fevola, Garlett, Waite, Hamill, Minton-Connell.
Defence not quite so good - Tuohy, Jones, Henderson, Massie, Yarran, Russell, Beaumont
Plus Allan, Jacobs, Robinson, Murphy, Gibbs, Grigg, Hampson, Menzel for some sort of unbalanced 22.
Their forward line is better than ours, our defence better than theirs.
2 Likes
I nominate GWS
b: Hombsch Plowman Tomlinson
hb: Wilson Marchbank Williams
c: Adams Steele Scully
hf: Smith Boyd Patton
f: Bruce Cameron Hoskin-Elliott
R; Lobb Shiel Teloar
int: Caldwell, Hately, Setterfield Townsend,
Emg: Giles, Miles, McCarthy Kennedy
2 Likes
Oh ok. I just thought ex players.
There are a lot of KP hacks who they picked up with high picks.
- Patton
- Boyd
- Plowman
- Marchbank
- Hombsch
Their midfield loss in unbelievable…and they still have a great midfield there still.
They were bad in identifying KPPs but great with midfield selections…like Opposite to Dodoro.
1 Like
My bad…I worded it poorly.
It’s so good we can’t even fit Townsend in.
1 Like
Sheeds as coach.
2 Likes
McPhee?
Camporeale too?
1 Like
FF - LEROY MCKERNAN DELL’OLIO
That will teach me to use a list of trades on a Carlton fans website!
Could also add in Bond, Harrison & McKernan.
Given the weakness of the midfield, Olarenshaw and Prior would be possibilities.
1 Like
How would old Rhino make a ‘best’ team??
Hawks team would be decent:
Hodge
Mitchell
Lewis
Jarman
Franklin
Morris
Robran
Anderson
Dear
Gowers
Crow
McDonald
Barnard
Minton-Connell
Scott
Collica
Croad
McPharlin
Chick
Harford
Thompson
Hay
Everitt
Kennedy
McGlynn
Savage
Cheney
Anderson
Hill
2 Likes
Really we should rule out guys who left in the very twilight of their careers to eke out an extra season or two, or to transition into coaching.
1 Like
Does Milne count on a technicality?
Updated from feedback:
T.Watson, M.Johnson and Olarenshaw in.
Hardwick Carlise Solomon
M.Johnson Richards Saad
Blumfield Wanganeen Olarenshaw
Caracella J.Daniher Fantasia
Kickett Salmon Cummings
Ryder Heffernan T.Watson
B: Hibberd Lovett Houli Melksham
Emergencies: Crameri Monfries Colyer Cockatoo-Collins Jacobs Manton Barnes O’Connor
1 Like