Blatant cheating by umpires - “having a ‘mare tonight” (Part 1)

You know it’s getting obvious when the commentators are on your side with umpiring.

I have not done the numbers but I would think we are skirting the edges of a significant outlier on the last three weeks. If I had time I’d like to do a by qtr analysis compared to score position on the AFL and find out the baseline and then see if there are any significant elements to it.

I think umpire bias is a real thing in the AFL and I also think it’s heavily dependant on AFL umpiring directives of the week. Nothing about a particular team, just what’s in the media the week before.

Take the wasting time from stringer last week now McKernan this week. Clearly been worded up and want to ‘enforce the rule’. I’m sure we weren’t the only club burnt with that one this week.

The thing about umpiring is that it should be to a certain extent random and fair and thus fit a relatively normal distribution. Meaning that any great outliers with consistency could be identified and shown to be heavily biased. You could almost prove the cheating if there was any.

6 Likes

Yeah and in the last 3 games the differential has been horrificly biased.

1 Like

There is no agenda against us. This was pure incompetence.
Inconsistency on the day is inevitable with 3 or 4 umpires.
More worrying was the umps realised how bad they were and tried to even up on 2 occasions.
That was when we saw the power of affirmation and we aren’t anywhere near as shrill as WCE or kochie’s ferals.

2 Likes

I really feel for the players.
They were competitive and worked tirelessly for three quarters, regardless of the umps horrific decisions. Demoralising for them as they continued to put their bodies in, especially Merrett, Heppell and Smith.
I admire their calm and congratulate them for continuing to “put in” knowing what we know, that they will get no fair assistance from the umps.

2 Likes

When Stephenson deliberately ran out of bounds after being run down in the 1st qtr I knew we were in for a bad day. As blatant an infringement you can get but no, throw it in. FMD.

13 Likes

Ch 7 commentator, Bruce Taylor says, during game “frees are 15 to 4. No guessing who is favoured by that. ha ha ha”. Almost verbatim.

1 Like

The AFL do bitterness and resentment quietly, very well, don’t they?

If they are NOT happy about JT and JB in court, just wait until Bruce Francis gets into the box, with his ten thousand files. ■■■!!!

2 Likes

Just heard Jon Faine (Brisbane supporter) on ABC radio saying that the umpiring against Essendon was some of the most biased he has ever seen.

12 Likes

Heard the same thing!
Astounding, obviously not AFL accredited.
WOB should have been listening.

When Carton supporters contact me to tell me we were robbed of important momentum through bias umpiring something is seriously wrong and obvious to others.

15 Likes

that’s alright, his mate Peter “i love the afl gobble gobble gobble” Gordon will clear that right up for him.

5 Likes

Should we do the numbers? Odds are the worst 3 game differential since Hird told the media that Demetriou knew.

Some amazing coincidences.

9 Likes

I had the same. A few carlton, brisbane and even Collingwood supporters said it to me. The Collingwood supporter said they were that biased that even though they won, they dont want to win like that.

5 Likes

I love a good conspiracy theory but to suggest umpires “deliberately cheat” is a bridge too far, although the bias against has reached alarming levels of consistency something is definitely going on. Is it simply a case of the higher ranked team getting the rub of the green - which has always been the way?

As supporters the club MUST let us know what action they’re taking to address the problem. I want to hear the coach say something, that they’ve at least spoken to the umpires department. I wish the media would make an issue of the injustice but that won’t happen because the umps are a protected species. Hey, there’s one constructive thing Robbo could do on 360 for his club and that is show a collage of bad calls/non calls. Now would create a stir, something he lives for.

4 Likes

Random footy supporters are seeing my lanyard today and saying damn you guys got killed by the Umps yesterday lol

2 Likes

AFL TO REVIEW TACKLING RULES

The Herald Age
By Rocky IV

After a series of contentious decisions at the MCG in yesterdays clash between Essendon and Collingwood, the AFL and the umpiring department have announced this morning a review into the rules around holding the ball and illegal disposal.

The issue was bought to a head by a copy book perfect tackle by Essendons Devon Smith on Collingwood player Jack Crisp. Crisp has since stated he was inspired by World Cup menace Neymar in crying for a free kick and holding his head after the tackle made impact on his shoulder. “He kept getting free kicks over in Russia when nothing happened to him, so I figured I should try it and it really works”, Crisp said in an interview after the game.

Since the days when a young and upcoming Moses sauntered across halfback for the Jerusalem Jews and racked up possessions seemingly at will, the tackle from Smith is the way all players have been taught in order to receive a holding the ball decision in their favour. However given the clear instructions the umpires were given in yesterday game to favour Collingwood as much, and as blatantly, and as often, as possible, this mornings announcement comes as no surprise to Essendon fans.

“Look this announcement won’t come as a surprise to Essendon fans”, umpires boss Grant Williams said this morning. “We just need to clarify what will be paid and what wont be paid as a free kick in games where Essendon are involved”.

While stating that the other 17 teams in the competition would have been paid a free kick for the tackle laid by Smith, particularly West Coast at Optus Stadium, Williams said the new rules would be applied only Essendon games.

“Once the opposition player collects the ball, the onus is on the Essendon player to tackle fairly and legally. This will now involve a verbal request, or warning, by the Essendon player that they intend to tackle the player with the ball”, he continued.

“The tackle can then only proceed if the opposition player acknowledges said request and replies in the affirmative that they are happy to be tackled. If the opposition player says they would prefer not to be tackled, it is then on the Essendon player to allow free passage for the play to continue. If the oppositions player response is ignored by the Essendon player a free kick, a 50m penalty and an umpires report will be made. Minimum suspension will be four weeks depending on what we determine the severity of the tackle is. For example Smiths heinous assault on Crisp would result in a life ban from football and a possible prison sentence”

When asked what then constitutes a legal tackle should the opposition player state that they don’t mind being tackled, Williams scoffed at the suggestion and said “I don’t think we’ll have to cross that bridge”.

Essendon CEO Xavier Campbell welcomed the AFL’s new initiative and said the club was once again thrilled to be singled out and made an example of by the games governing body and hoped it would continue to happen in future.

“Look we’re thrilled to be singled out and made an example of by the games governing body”, Campbell stated, “We can only hope it continues to happen in the future”.

Essendon players this morning declined to comment, except Brendon Goddard who said roughly nine sentences, none of which we’re able to print, while pointing in seven different directions.

74 Likes

I said at the start of the season that we are going to get screwed consistently.

From now on, we need to be better than the opposition and the umpires. It’s the reality unfortunately. It’s important that supporters keep the pressure on the AFL regarding this. But the club must be committed to taking the umpiring out of the equation, as we did against West Coast and North Melbourne.

6 Likes

Yep My boss whos mad Hawks and dislikes the bombers thought we were hard done by in the Eagles and North games.

1 Like

And if we are going to give away a free kick, make them earn it like Bellchambers knee into grundy.
But maybe that just fired grundy up.

1 Like

In the 15 games to date lopsided decisions have happened in 8 (191:121 in total), equal number in 6 and 1 (19:12) where decisions favoured Essendon. 1 out of 15! Now, that is some serious bulls_t

1 Like